200K+ Crowdsourced Political Arguments for a New Chilean Constitution
In this paper we present the dataset of 200,000+ political arguments produced in the local phase of the 2016 Chilean constitutional process. We describe the human processing of this data by the government officials, and the manual tagging of arguments performed by members of our research group. Afterwards we focus on classification tasks that mimic the human processes, comparing linear methods with neural network architectures. The experiments show that some of the manual tasks are suitable for automatization. In particular, the best methods achieve a 90{\%} top-5 accuracy in a multi-class classification of arguments, and 65{\%} macro-averaged F1-score for tagging arguments according to a three-part argumentation model.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Argument MiningGeneral ClassificationMulti-class ClassificationSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Epistemic Constitutionalism Or: how to avoid coherence bias
Large language models increasingly function as artificial reasoners: they evaluate arguments, assign credibility, and express confidence. Yet their belief-forming behavior is governed by implicit, uninspected epistemic p…
Inferring Political Alignments of Twitter Users: A case study on 2017 Turkish constitutional referendum
Increasing popularity of Twitter in politics is subject to commercial and academic interest. To fully exploit the merits of this platform, reaching the target audience with desired political leanings is critical. This pa…
Minimal Stable Voting Rules
In this paper, I characterize minimal stable voting rules and minimal self-stable constitutions (i.e., pairs of voting rules) for societies in which only power matters. To do so, I first let players' preference profiles …
Politicians' Willingness to Agree: Evidence from the interactions in Twitter of Chilean Deputies
Measuring the number of "likes" in Twitter and the number of bills voted in favor by the members of the Chilean Chambers of Deputies. We empirically study how signals of agreement in Twitter translates into cross-cutting…
A Contextual Topic Modeling and Content Analysis of Iranian laws and Regulations
A constitution is the highest legal document of a country and serves as a guide for the establishment of other laws. The constitution defines the political principles, structure, hierarchy, position, and limits of the po…