A comparative study of non-deep learning, deep learning, and ensemble learning methods for sunspot number prediction
Solar activity has significant impacts on human activities and health. One most commonly used measure of solar activity is the sunspot number. This paper compares three important non-deep learning models, four popular deep learning models, and their five ensemble models in forecasting sunspot numbers. In particular, we propose an ensemble model called XGBoost-DL, which uses XGBoost as a two-level nonlinear ensemble method to combine the deep learning models. Our XGBoost-DL achieves the best forecasting performance (RMSE = 25.70 and MAE = 19.82) in the comparison, outperforming the best non-deep learning model SARIMA (RMSE = 54.11 and MAE = 45.51), the best deep learning model Informer (RMSE = 29.90 and MAE = 22.35) and the NASA's forecast (RMSE = 48.38 and MAE = 38.45). Our XGBoost-DL forecasts a peak sunspot number of 133.47 in May 2025 for Solar Cycle 25 and 164.62 in November 2035 for Solar Cycle 26, similar to but later than the NASA's at 137.7 in October 2024 and 161.2 in December 2034. An open-source Python package of our XGBoost-DL for the sunspot number prediction is available at https://github.com/yd1008/ts_ensemble_sunspot.
Code (1)
Tasks
Deep LearningEnsemble LearningMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Image patch analysis and clustering of sunspots: a dimensionality reduction approach
Sunspots, as seen in white light or continuum images, are associated with regions of high magnetic activity on the Sun, visible on magnetogram images. Their complexity is correlated with explosive solar activity and so c…
ClusteringDimensionality ReductionFilling Factors of Sunspots in SODISM Images
Received: 1st December 2018; Accepted: 18th February 2019; Published: 1st April 2019 Abstract: The calculated filling factors (FFs) for a feature reflect the fraction of the solar disc covered by that feature, and the as…
Image patch analysis of sunspots and active regions. I. Intrinsic dimension and correlation analysis
The flare-productivity of an active region is observed to be related to its spatial complexity. Mount Wilson or McIntosh sunspot classifications measure such complexity but in a categorical way, and may therefore not use…
ClusteringDictionary LearningRanking news feed updates on social media: A comparative study of supervised models
Social media users are overwhelmed by a large number of updates displayed chronologically in their news feed. Moreover, most updates are irrelevant. Ranking news feed updates by relevance has been proposed to help users …
Ensemble LearningNews RecommendationRecommendation SystemsSocial Media Popularity PredictionDistribution of residual autocorrelations for multiplicative seasonal ARMA models with uncorrelated but non-independent error terms
In this paper we consider portmanteau tests for testing the adequacy of multiplicative seasonal autoregressive moving-average (SARMA) models under the assumption that the errors are uncorrelated but not necessarily indep…