A linguistically-motivated evaluation methodology for unraveling model's abilities in reading comprehension tasks
We introduce an evaluation methodology for reading comprehension tasks based on the intuition that certain examples, by the virtue of their linguistic complexity, consistently yield lower scores regardless of model size or architecture. We capitalize on semantic frame annotation for characterizing this complexity, and study seven complexity factors that may account for model's difficulty. We first deploy this methodology on a carefully annotated French reading comprehension benchmark showing that two of those complexity factors are indeed good predictors of models' failure, while others are less so. We further deploy our methodology on a well studied English benchmark by using Chat-GPT as a proxy for semantic annotation. Our study reveals that fine-grained linguisticallymotivated automatic evaluation of a reading comprehension task is not only possible, but helps understand models' abilities to handle specific linguistic characteristics of input examples. It also shows that current state-of-the-art models fail with some for those characteristics which suggests that adequately handling them requires more than merely increasing model size.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Reading ComprehensionSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
ARRAU: Linguistically-Motivated Annotation of Anaphoric Descriptions
This paper presents a second release of the ARRAU dataset: a multi-domain corpus with thorough linguistically motivated annotation of anaphora and related phenomena. Building upon the first release almost a decade ago, a…
Unraveling the Complexity of Memory in RL Agents: an Approach for Classification and Evaluation
The incorporation of memory into agents is essential for numerous tasks within the domain of Reinforcement Learning (RL). In particular, memory is paramount for tasks that require the utilization of past information, ada…
Reinforcement Learning (RL)Fine-grained evaluation of Quality Estimation for Machine translation based on a linguistically motivated Test Suite
Towards a Diagnostic and Predictive Evaluation Methodology for Sequence Labeling Tasks
Standard evaluation in NLP typically indicates that system A is better on average than system B, but it provides little info on how to improve performance and, what is worse, it should not come as a surprise if B ends up…
Fine-grained evaluation of Quality Estimation for Machine translation based on a linguistically-motivated Test Suite
We present an alternative method of evaluating Quality Estimation systems, which is based on a linguistically-motivated Test Suite. We create a test-set consisting of 14 linguistic error categories and we gather for each…
Machine TranslationTranslation