An Exploratory Study of Argumentative Writing by Young Students: A Transformer-based Approach
We present a computational exploration of argument critique writing by young students. Middle school students were asked to criticize an argument presented in the prompt, focusing on identifying and explaining the reasoning flaws. This task resembles an established college-level argument critique task. Lexical and discourse features that utilize detailed domain knowledge to identify critiques exist for the college task but do not perform well on the young students data. Instead, transformer-based architecture (e.g., BERT) fine-tuned on a large corpus of critique essays from the college task performs much better (over 20% improvement in F1 score). Analysis of the performance of various configurations of the system suggests that while children's writing does not exhibit the standard discourse structure of an argumentative essay, it does share basic local sequential structures with the more mature writers.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
eRevise+RF: A Writing Evaluation System for Assessing Student Essay Revisions and Providing Formative Feedback
The ability to revise essays in response to feedback is important for students' writing success. An automated writing evaluation (AWE) system that supports students in revising their essays is thus essential. We present …
Automated Writing EvaluationA School Student Essay Corpus for Analyzing Interactions of Argumentative Structure and Quality
Learning argumentative writing is challenging. Besides writing fundamentals such as syntax and grammar, learners must select and arrange argument components meaningfully to create high-quality essays. To support argument…
Argument MiningAnnotation and Classification of Evidence and Reasoning Revisions in Argumentative Writing
Automated writing evaluation systems can improve students' writing insofar as students attend to the feedback provided and revise their essay drafts in ways aligned with such feedback. Existing research on revision of ar…
Automated Writing EvaluationSentenceMachine-assisted writing evaluation: Exploring pre-trained language models in analyzing argumentative moves
The study investigates the efficacy of pre-trained language models (PLMs) in analyzing argumentative moves in a longitudinal learner corpus. Prior studies on argumentative moves often rely on qualitative analysis and man…
Identifying Editor Roles in Argumentative Writing from Student Revision Histories
We present a method for identifying editor roles from students' revision behaviors during argumentative writing. We first develop a method for applying a topic modeling algorithm to identify a set of editor roles from a …
Position