Are Sample-Efficient NLP Models More Robust?
Recent results in image classification and extractive question answering have observed that pre-trained models trained on less in-distribution data have better out-of-distribution performance. However, it is unclear how broadly these trends hold. We conduct a large empirical study across three tasks, three broadly-applicable modeling interventions (increasing model size, using a different adaptation method, and pre-training on more data), and 14 diverse datasets to investigate the relationship between sample efficiency (amount of data needed to reach a given ID accuracy) and robustness (how models fare on OOD evaluation). We find that higher sample efficiency is only correlated with better average OOD robustness on some modeling interventions and tasks, but not others. On individual datasets, models with lower sample efficiency can even be more robust. These results suggest that general-purpose methods for improving sample efficiency are unlikely to yield universal OOD robustness improvements, since such improvements are highly dataset- and task-dependent. Even in an era of large, multi-purpose pretrained models, task-specific decisions may often be necessary for OOD generalization.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Extractive Question-Answeringimage-classificationImage ClassificationQuestion AnsweringSST-2Methods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
One for More: Selecting Generalizable Samples for Generalizable ReID Model
Current training objectives of existing person Re-IDentification (ReID) models only ensure that the loss of the model decreases on selected training batch, with no regards to the performance on samples outside the batch.…
Person Re-IdentificationNegative Samples are at Large: Leveraging Hard-distance Elastic Loss for Re-identification
We present a Momentum Re-identification (MoReID) framework that can leverage a very large number of negative samples in training for general re-identification task. The design of this framework is inspired by Momentum Co…
TripletSynthetic Hard Negative Samples for Contrastive Learning
Contrastive learning has emerged as an essential approach for self-supervised learning in visual representation learning. The central objective of contrastive learning is to maximize the similarities between two augmente…
Contrastive LearningRepresentation LearningSelf-Supervised LearningFeature Extraction Framework based on Contrastive Learning with Adaptive Positive and Negative Samples
In this study, we propose a feature extraction framework based on contrastive learning with adaptive positive and negative samples (CL-FEFA) that is suitable for unsupervised, supervised, and semi-supervised single-view …
Contrastive LearningDouble Correction Framework for Denoising Recommendation
As its availability and generality in online services, implicit feedback is more commonly used in recommender systems. However, implicit feedback usually presents noisy samples in real-world recommendation scenarios (suc…
DenoisingModel OptimizationRecommendation Systems