Balancing the Benefits of Vaccination: an Envy-Free Strategy
The Covid-19 pandemic revealed the difficulties of vaccinating a population under the circumstances marked by urgency and limited availability of doses while balancing benefits associated with distinct guidelines satisfying specific ethical criteria (J.W. Wu, S.D. John, E.Y. Adashi, Allocating Vaccines in the Pandemic: The Ethical Dimension, The Am. J. of Medicine V.33(11): 1241 - 1242 (2020)). We offer a vaccination strategy that may be useful in this regard. It relies on the mathematical concept of envy-freeness. We consider finding balance by allocating the resource among individuals that seem to be heterogeneous concerning the direct and indirect benefits of vaccination, depending on age. The proposed strategy adapts a constructive approach in the literature based on Sperner`s Lemma to point out an approximate division of doses guaranteeing that both benefits are optimized each time a batch becomes available. Applications using data about population age distributions from diverse countries suggest that, among other features, this strategy maintains the desired balance throughout the entire vaccination period.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
LEMMASimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Strategy-proof and Envy-free Mechanisms for House Allocation
We consider the problem of allocating indivisible objects to agents when agents have strict preferences over objects. There are inherent trade-offs between competing notions of efficiency, fairness and incentives in assi…
FairnessReforming an Envy-Free Matching
We consider the problem of reforming an envy-free matching when each agent is assigned a single item. Given an envy-free matching, we consider an operation to exchange the item of an agent with an unassigned item preferr…
Envy-Free but Still Unfair: Envy-Freeness Up To One Item (EF-1) in Personalized Recommendation
Envy-freeness and the relaxation to Envy-freeness up to one item (EF-1) have been used as fairness concepts in the economics, game theory, and social choice literatures since the 1960s, and have recently gained popularit…
Recommendation SystemsEnvy-Free Classification
In classic fair division problems such as cake cutting and rent division, envy-freeness requires that each individual (weakly) prefer his allocation to anyone else's. On a conceptual level, we argue that envy-freeness al…
ClassificationFairnessGeneral ClassificationThe lattice of envy-free many-to-many matchings with contracts
We study envy-free allocations in a many-to-many matching model with contracts in which agents on one side of the market (doctors) are endowed with substitutable choice functions and agents on the other side of the marke…
BlockingPosition