A Bayesian Model for Bivariate Causal Inference
We address the problem of two-variable causal inference without intervention. This task is to infer an existing causal relation between two random variables, i.e. $X \rightarrow Y$ or $Y \rightarrow X$ , from purely observational data. As the option to modify a potential cause is not given in many situations only structural properties of the data can be used to solve this ill-posed problem. We briefly review a number of state-of-the-art methods for this, including very recent ones. A novel inference method is introduced, Bayesian Causal Inference (BCI), which assumes a generative Bayesian hierarchical model to pursue the strategy of Bayesian model selection. In the adopted model the distribution of the cause variable is given by a Poisson lognormal distribution, which allows to explicitly regard the discrete nature of datasets, correlations in the parameter spaces, as well as the variance of probability densities on logarithmic scales. We assume Fourier diagonal Field covariance operators. The model itself is restricted to use cases where a direct causal relation $X \rightarrow Y$ has to be decided against a relation $Y \rightarrow X$ , therefore we compare it other methods for this exact problem setting. The generative model assumed provides synthetic causal data for benchmarking our model in comparison to existing State-of-the-art models, namely LiNGAM , ANM-HSIC , ANM-MML , IGCI and CGNN . We explore how well the above methods perform in case of high noise settings, strongly discretized data and very sparse data. BCI performs generally reliable with synthetic data as well as with the real world TCEP benchmark set, with an accuracy comparable to state-of-the-art algorithms. We discuss directions for the future development of BCI .
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
BenchmarkingCausal InferencemodelModel SelectionRelationMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Bivariate Causal Discovery and its Applications to Gene Expression and Imaging Data Analysis
The mainstream of research in genetics, epigenetics and imaging data analysis focuses on statistical association or exploring statistical dependence between variables. Despite their significant progresses in genetic rese…
Causal DiscoveryCausal InferenceIncorporating structural uncertainty in causal decision making
Practitioners making decisions based on causal effects typically ignore structural uncertainty. We analyze when this uncertainty is consequential enough to warrant methodological solutions (Bayesian model averaging over …
Causal InferenceDecision MakingBivariate Causal Discovery using Bayesian Model Selection
Much of the causal discovery literature prioritises guaranteeing the identifiability of causal direction in statistical models. For structures within a Markov equivalence class, this requires strong assumptions which may…
Causal DiscoverymodelModel SelectionCausal Inference from Slowly Varying Nonstationary Processes
Causal inference from observational data following the restricted structural causal model (SCM) framework hinges largely on the asymmetry between cause and effect from the data generating mechanisms, such as non-Gaussian…
Causal DiscoveryCausal IdentificationCausal InferenceTime Series+1Causal Inference from Slowly Varying Nonstationary Processes
Causal inference from observational data following the restricted structural causal models (SCM) framework hinges largely on the asymmetry between cause and effect from the data generating mechanisms, such as non-Gaussia…
Causal IdentificationCausal InferenceTime Series