Bayesian regression explains how human participants handle parameter uncertainty
The human brain copes with sensory uncertainty in accordance with Bayes' rule. However, it is unknown how the brain makes predictions in the presence of parameter uncertainty. Here, we tested whether and how humans take parameter uncertainty into account in a regression task. Participants extrapolated a parabola from a limited number of noisy points, shown on a computer screen. The quadratic parameter was drawn from a prior distribution, unknown to the observers. We tested whether human observers take full advantage of the given information, including the likelihood function of the observed points and the prior distribution of the quadratic parameter. We compared human performance with Bayesian regression, which is the (Bayes) optimal solution to this problem, and three sub-optimal models, namely maximum likelihood regression, prior regression and maximum a posteriori regression, which are simpler to compute. Our results clearly show that humans use Bayesian regression. We further investigated several variants of Bayesian regression models depending on how the generative noise is treated and found that participants act in line with the more sophisticated version.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
regressionSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Closed-Loop phase selection in EEG-TMS using Bayesian Optimization
Research on transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) combined with encephalography feedback (EEG-TMS) has shown that the phase of the sensorimotor mu rhythm is predictive of corticospinal excitability. Thus, if the subjec…
Bayesian OptimizationEEGregressionRhythmGP-BART: a novel Bayesian additive regression trees approach using Gaussian processes
The Bayesian additive regression trees (BART) model is an ensemble method extensively and successfully used in regression tasks due to its consistently strong predictive performance and its ability to quantify uncertaint…
Gaussian ProcessesregressionA Bayesian Decision Tree Algorithm
Bayesian Decision Trees are known for their probabilistic interpretability. However, their construction can sometimes be costly. In this article we present a general Bayesian Decision Tree algorithm applicable to both re…
General ClassificationregressionA Study of Human Gaze Behavior During Visual Crowd Counting
In this paper, we describe our study on how humans allocate their attention during visual crowd counting. Using an eye tracker, we collect gaze behavior of human participants who are tasked with counting the number of pe…
Crowd CountingFuzzy Bayesian Learning
In this paper we propose a novel approach for learning from data using rule based fuzzy inference systems where the model parameters are estimated using Bayesian inference and Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) techniques. …
Bayesian InferenceGeneral Classificationregression