Beyond Cortisol! Physiological Indicators of Welfare for Dogs: Deficits, Misunderstandings and Opportunities
This paper aims to initiate new conversations about the use of physiological indicators when assessing the welfare of dogs. There are significant concerns about construct validity - whether the measures used accurately reflect welfare. The goal is to provide recommendations for future inquiry and encourage debate. We acknowledge that the scientific understanding of animal welfare has evolved and bring attention to the shortcomings of commonly used biomarkers like cortisol. These indicators are frequently used in isolation and with limited salient dog descriptors, so fail to reflect the canine experience adequately. Using a systems approach, we explore various physiological systems and alternative indicators, such as heart rate variability and oxidative stress, to address this limitation. It is essential to consider factors like age, body weight, breed, and sex when interpreting these biomarkers correctly, and researchers should report on these in their studies. This discussion identifies possible indicators for both positive and negative experiences. In conclusion, we advocate for a practical, evidence-based approach to assessing indicators of canine welfare, including non-invasive collection methods. We acknowledge the complexity of evaluating experiential responses in dogs across different situations and the need for continued work to improve practices and refine terminology. This will enhance our ability to accurately understand welfare and improve the wellbeing of dogs, serving to inform standards of animal welfare assessment. We hope this will promote more fundamental research in canine physiology to improve construct validity, leading to better practices, ultimately improving the lives of dogs.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Heart Rate VariabilityMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Insights on Modelling Physiological, Appraisal, and Affective Indicators of Stress using Audio Features
Stress is a major threat to well-being that manifests in a variety of physiological and mental symptoms. Utilising speech samples collected while the subject is undergoing an induced stress episode has recently shown pro…
How to disentangle psychobiological stress reactivity and recovery: A comparison of model-based and non-compartmental analyses of cortisol concentrations
This article seeks to address the prevailing issue of how to measure specific process components of psychobiological stress responses. Particularly the change of cortisol secretion due to stress exposure has been discuss…
Chronic stress may disrupt covariant fluctuations of vitamin D and cortisol plasma levels in pregnant sheep during the last trimester: a preliminary report
Psychosocial stress during pregnancy is a known contributor to preterm birth, but also has been increasingly appreciated as an in utero insult acting long-term on prenatal and postnatal neurodevelopmental trajectories. T…
Surprise! Using Physiological Stress for Allostatic Regulation Under the Active Inference Framework [Pre-Print]
Allostasis proposes that long-term viability of a living system is achieved through anticipatory adjustments of its physiology and behaviour: emphasising physiological and affective stress as an adaptive state of adaptat…
PredictionTranscriptional Activation of Elephant Shark Mineralocorticoid Receptor by Corticosteroids, Progesterone and Spironolactone
We report the analysis of activation by corticosteroids and progesterone of full-length mineralocorticoid receptor (MR) from elephant shark, a cartilaginous fish belonging to the oldest group of jawed vertebrates. Based …