Claim Check-Worthiness Detection: How Well do LLMs Grasp Annotation Guidelines?
The increasing threat of disinformation calls for automating parts of the fact-checking pipeline. Identifying text segments requiring fact-checking is known as claim detection (CD) and claim check-worthiness detection (CW), the latter incorporating complex domain-specific criteria of worthiness and often framed as a ranking task. Zero- and few-shot LLM prompting is an attractive option for both tasks, as it bypasses the need for labeled datasets and allows verbalized claim and worthiness criteria to be directly used for prompting. We evaluate the LLMs' predictive and calibration accuracy on five CD/CW datasets from diverse domains, each utilizing a different worthiness criterion. We investigate two key aspects: (1) how best to distill factuality and worthiness criteria into a prompt and (2) what amount of context to provide for each claim. To this end, we experiment with varying the level of prompt verbosity and the amount of contextual information provided to the model. Our results show that optimal prompt verbosity is domain-dependent, adding context does not improve performance, and confidence scores can be directly used to produce reliable check-worthiness rankings.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Fact CheckingSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
HintsOfTruth: A Multimodal Checkworthiness Detection Dataset with Real and Synthetic Claims
Misinformation can be countered with fact-checking, but the process is costly and slow. Identifying checkworthy claims is the first step, where automation can help scale fact-checkers' efforts. However, detection methods…
BenchmarkingFact CheckingMisinformationClaim Check-Worthiness Detection as Positive Unlabelled Learning
As the first step of automatic fact checking, claim check-worthiness detection is a critical component of fact checking systems. There are multiple lines of research which study this problem: check-worthiness ranking fro…
Fact CheckingRumour DetectionSentenceCheckworthiness in Automatic Claim Detection Models: Definitions and Analysis of Datasets
Public, professional and academic interest in automated fact-checking has drastically increased over the past decade, with many aiming to automate one of the first steps in a fact-check procedure: the selection of so-cal…
Fact CheckingFactFinders at CheckThat! 2024: Refining Check-worthy Statement Detection with LLMs through Data Pruning
The rapid dissemination of information through social media and the Internet has posed a significant challenge for fact-checking, among others in identifying check-worthy claims that fact-checkers should pay attention to…
Fact CheckingPrompt EngineeringWhen Hate Meets Facts: LLMs-in-the-Loop for Check-worthiness Detection in Hate Speech
Hateful content online is often expressed using fact-like, not necessarily correct information, especially in coordinated online harassment campaigns and extremist propaganda. Failing to jointly address hate speech (HS) …