Committee Selection with Attribute Level Preferences
We consider the problem of committee selection from a fixed set of candidates where each candidate has multiple quantifiable attributes. To select the best possible committee, instead of voting for a candidate, a voter is allowed to approve the preferred attributes of a given candidate. Though attribute based preference is addressed in several contexts, committee selection problem with attribute approval of voters has not been attempted earlier. A committee formed on attribute preferences is more likely to be a better representative of the qualities desired by the voters and is less likely to be susceptible to collusion or manipulation. In this work, we provide a formal study of the different aspects of this problem and define properties of weak unanimity, strong unanimity, simple justified representations and compound justified representation, that are required to be satisfied by the selected committee. We show that none of the existing vote/approval aggregation rules satisfy these new properties for attribute aggregation. We describe a greedy approach for attribute aggregation that satisfies the first three properties, but not the fourth, i.e., compound justified representation, which we prove to be NP-complete. Furthermore, we prove that finding a committee with justified representation and the highest approval voting score is NP-complete.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
AttributeSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Computing and Testing Pareto Optimal Committees
Selecting a set of alternatives based on the preferences of agents is an important problem in committee selection and beyond. Among the various criteria put forth for the desirability of a committee, Pareto optimality is…
Efficient Algorithms for Electing Successive Committees
In a recently introduced model of successive committee elections (Bredereck et al., AAAI-20) for a given set of ordinal or approval preferences one aims to find a sequence of a given length of "best" same-size committees…
Multi-Attribute Proportional Representation
We consider the following problem in which a given number of items has to be chosen from a predefined set. Each item is described by a vector of attributes and for each attribute there is a desired distribution that the …
AttributeA Committee of Convolutional Neural Networks for Image Classication in the Concurrent Presence of Feature and Label Noise
Image classification has become a ubiquitous task. Models trained on good quality data achieve accuracy which in some application domains is already above human-level performance. Unfortunately, real-world data are quite…
Attributeimage-classificationImage ClassificationMultiwinner Voting with Fairness Constraints
Multiwinner voting rules are used to select a small representative subset of candidates or items from a larger set given the preferences of voters. However, if candidates have sensitive attributes such as gender or ethni…
AttributeFairness