Comparing Causal Frameworks: Potential Outcomes, Structural Models, Graphs, and Abstractions
The aim of this paper is to make clear and precise the relationship between the Rubin causal model (RCM) and structural causal model (SCM) frameworks for causal inference. Adopting a neutral logical perspective, and drawing on previous work, we show what is required for an RCM to be representable by an SCM. A key result then shows that every RCM -- including those that violate algebraic principles implied by the SCM framework -- emerges as an abstraction of some representable RCM. Finally, we illustrate the power of this conciliatory perspective by pinpointing an important role for SCM principles in classic applications of RCMs; conversely, we offer a characterization of the algebraic constraints implied by a graph, helping to substantiate further comparisons between the two frameworks.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Causal InferenceSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Distribution-consistency Structural Causal Models
In the field of causal modeling, potential outcomes (PO) and structural causal models (SCMs) stand as the predominant frameworks. However, these frameworks face notable challenges in practically modeling counterfactuals,…
counterfactualCounterfactual ReasoningDecision MakingFeature selection in stratification estimators of causal effects: lessons from potential outcomes, causal diagrams, and structural equations
What is the ideal regression (if any) for estimating average causal effects? We study this question in the setting of discrete covariates, deriving expressions for the finite-sample variance of various stratification est…
feature selectionregressionAnswering Causal Queries at Layer 3 with DiscoSCMs-Embracing Heterogeneity
In the realm of causal inference, Potential Outcomes (PO) and Structural Causal Models (SCM) are recognized as the principal frameworks.However, when it comes to Layer 3 valuations -- counterfactual queries deeply entwin…
Causal InferencecounterfactualCounterfactual InferencePhilosophyAn introduction to Causal Modelling
This tutorial provides a concise introduction to modern causal modeling by integrating potential outcomes and graphical methods. We motivate causal questions such as counterfactual reasoning under interventions and defin…
BlockingcounterfactualCounterfactual ReasoningReinterpreting demand estimation
This paper connects the literature on demand estimation to the literature on causal inference by interpreting nonparametric structural assumptions as restrictions on counterfactual outcomes. It offers nontrivial and equi…
Causal Inferencecounterfactual