Comparing representations of biological data learned with different AI paradigms, augmenting and cropping strategies
Recent advances in computer vision and robotics enabled automated large-scale biological image analysis. Various machine learning approaches have been successfully applied to phenotypic profiling. However, it remains unclear how they compare in terms of biological feature extraction. In this study, we propose a simple CNN architecture and implement 4 different representation learning approaches. We train 16 deep learning setups on the 770k cancer cell images dataset under identical conditions, using different augmenting and cropping strategies. We compare the learned representations by evaluating multiple metrics for each of three downstream tasks: i) distance-based similarity analysis of known drugs, ii) classification of drugs versus controls, iii) clustering within cell lines. We also compare training times and memory usage. Among all tested setups, multi-crops and random augmentations generally improved performance across tasks, as expected. Strikingly, self-supervised (implicit contrastive learning) models showed competitive performance being up to 11 times faster to train. Self-supervised regularized learning required the most of memory and computation to deliver arguably the most informative features. We observe that no single combination of augmenting and cropping strategies consistently results in top performance across tasks and recommend prospective research directions.
Code (1)
Tasks
Contrastive LearningRepresentation LearningSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Universal dimensions of visual representation
Do neural network models of vision learn brain-aligned representations because they share architectural constraints and task objectives with biological vision or because they learn universal features of natural image pro…
Learning grid cells by predictive coding
Grid cells in the medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) of the mammalian brain exhibit a strikingly regular hexagonal firing field over space. These cells are learned after birth and are thought to support spatial navigation bu…
Comparing noisy neural population dynamics using optimal transport distances
Biological and artificial neural systems form high-dimensional neural representations that underpin their computational capabilities. Methods for quantifying geometric similarity in neural representations have become a p…
Gaussian ProcessesImage GenerationLessons from reinforcement learning for biological representations of space
Neuroscientists postulate 3D representations in the brain in a variety of different coordinate frames (e.g. 'head-centred', 'hand-centred' and 'world-based'). Recent advances in reinforcement learning demonstrate a quite…
reinforcement-learningReinforcement LearningReinforcement Learning (RL)On the Mechanistic Interpretability of Neural Networks for Causality in Bio-statistics
Interpretable insights from predictive models remain critical in bio-statistics, particularly when assessing causality, where classical statistical and machine learning methods often provide inherent clarity. While Neura…
Causal Inference