Control Search Rankings, Control the World: What is a Good Search Engine?
This paper examines the ethical question, 'What is a good search engine?' Since search engines are gatekeepers of global online information, it is vital they do their job ethically well. While the Internet is now several decades old, the topic remains under-explored from interdisciplinary perspectives. This paper presents a novel role-based approach involving four ethical models of types of search engine behavior: Customer Servant, Librarian, Journalist, and Teacher. It explores these ethical models with reference to the research field of information retrieval, and by means of a case study involving the COVID-19 global pandemic. It also reflects on the four ethical models in terms of the history of search engine development, from earlier crude efforts in the 1990s, to the very recent prospect of Large Language Model-based conversational information seeking systems taking on the roles of established web search engines like Google. Finally, the paper outlines considerations that inform present and future regulation and accountability for search engines as they continue to evolve. The paper should interest information retrieval researchers and others interested in the ethics of search engines.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
EthicsInformation RetrievalLanguage ModelingLanguage ModellingLarge Language ModelRetrievalSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Assessing Viewpoint Diversity in Search Results Using Ranking Fairness Metrics
The way pages are ranked in search results influences whether the users of search engines are exposed to more homogeneous, or rather to more diverse viewpoints. However, this viewpoint diversity is not trivial to assess.…
DiversityFairnessWhat You See Is What You Get? The Impact of Representation Criteria on Human Bias in Hiring
Although systematic biases in decision-making are widely documented, the ways in which they emerge from different sources is less understood. We present a controlled experimental platform to study gender bias in hiring b…
Decision MakingMediators in Determining what Processing BERT Performs First
Probing neural models for the ability to perform downstream tasks using their activation patterns is often used to localize what parts of the network specialize in performing what tasks. However, little work addressed po…
Benchmarking the Benchmarks: Testing the Predictive Validity of Commonsense Benchmarks
Predicting LLM's capabilities on real-world tasks is essential, yet the extent to which performance on commonsense benchmarks predicts downstream performance remains underspecified. To establish the practical usability o…
MacArena: Benchmarking Computer Use Agents on an Online macOS Environment
Computer-use agents (CUAs) operate graphical user interfaces (GUIs) through vision and control primitives, and their capabilities have advanced rapidly, driven in part by standardized online evaluation benchmarks such as…
Reinforcement Learning