Cost optimisation of hybrid institutional incentives for promoting cooperation in finite populations
In this paper, we rigorously study the problem of cost optimisation of hybrid (mixed) institutional incentives, which are a plan of actions involving the use of reward and punishment by an external decision-maker, for maximising the level (or guaranteeing at least a certain level) of cooperative behaviour in a well-mixed, finite population of self-regarding individuals who interact via cooperation dilemmas (Donation Game or Public Goods Game). We show that a mixed incentive scheme can offer a more cost-efficient approach for providing incentives while ensuring the same level or standard of cooperation in the long-run. We establish the asymptotic behaviour (namely neutral drift, strong selection, and infinite-population limits). We prove the existence of a phase transition, obtaining the critical threshold of the strength of selection at which the monotonicity of the cost function changes and providing an algorithm for finding the optimal value of the individual incentive cost. Our analytical results are illustrated with numerical investigations. Overall, our analysis provides novel theoretical insights into the design of cost-efficient institutional incentive mechanisms for promoting the evolution of cooperation in stochastic systems.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Cost optimisation of individual-based institutional reward incentives for promoting cooperation in finite populations
In this paper, we study the problem of cost optimisation of individual-based institutional incentives (reward, punishment, and hybrid) for guaranteeing a certain minimal level of cooperative behaviour in a well-mixed, fi…
Cost of institutional incentives for promoting cooperation in $2\times2$ games and collective risk games
Prosocial behaviours, which appear to contradict Darwinian principles of individual payoff maximisation, have been extensively studied across multiple disciplines. Cooperation, requiring a personal cost for collective be…
Social welfare optimisation under institutional reward and punishment
Institutional incentives are widely used to promote cooperation among autonomous, self-regarding agents, from human societies to multi-agent and AI systems. Existing work typically treats incentive design as a bi-objecti…
Institutional AI: Governing LLM Collusion in Multi-Agent Cournot Markets via Public Governance Graphs
Multi-agent LLM ensembles can converge on coordinated, socially harmful equilibria. This paper advances an experimental framework for evaluating Institutional AI, our system-level approach to AI alignment that reframes a…
Evolutionary mechanisms that promote cooperation may not promote social welfare
Understanding the emergence of prosocial behaviours among self-interested individuals is an important problem in many scientific disciplines. Various mechanisms have been proposed to explain the evolution of such behavio…