Counterfactually Evaluating Explanations in Recommender Systems
Modern recommender systems face an increasing need to explain their recommendations. Despite considerable progress in this area, evaluating the quality of explanations remains a significant challenge for researchers and practitioners. Prior work mainly conducts human study to evaluate explanation quality, which is usually expensive, time-consuming, and prone to human bias. In this paper, we propose an offline evaluation method that can be computed without human involvement. To evaluate an explanation, our method quantifies its counterfactual impact on the recommendation. To validate the effectiveness of our method, we carry out an online user study. We show that, compared to conventional methods, our method can produce evaluation scores more correlated with the real human judgments, and therefore can serve as a better proxy for human evaluation. In addition, we show that explanations with high evaluation scores are considered better by humans. Our findings highlight the promising direction of using the counterfactual approach as one possible way to evaluate recommendation explanations.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
counterfactualRecommendation SystemsSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Learning to Counterfactually Explain Recommendations
Recommender system practitioners are facing increasing pressure to explain recommendations. We explore how to explain recommendations using counterfactual logic, i.e. "Had you not interacted with the following items, we …
counterfactualRecommendation SystemsvalidBi-NAS: Towards Effective and Personalized Explanation for Recommender Systems via Bi-Level Neural Architecture Search
Recommender systems are vital in helping users navigate vast amounts of information, offering personalized suggestions and effective explanations for these recommendations. While previous efforts have attempted to provid…
Neural Architecture SearchExplanation GenerationCan Offline Metrics Measure Explanation Goals? A Comparative Survey Analysis of Offline Explanation Metrics in Recommender Systems
Explanations in a Recommender System (RS) provide reasons for recommendations to users and can enhance transparency, persuasiveness, engagement, and trust-known as explanation goals. Evaluating the effectiveness of expla…
DiversityPersuasivenessRecommendation SystemsSentenceCombining Embedding-Based and Semantic-Based Models for Post-hoc Explanations in Recommender Systems
In today's data-rich environment, recommender systems play a crucial role in decision support systems. They provide to users personalized recommendations and explanations about these recommendations. Embedding-based mode…
Knowledge GraphsRecommendation SystemsDesigning Explanations for Group Recommender Systems
Explanations are used in recommender systems for various reasons. Users have to be supported in making (high-quality) decisions more quickly. Developers of recommender systems want to convince users to purchase specific …
Recommendation Systems