Decomposing Natural Logic Inferences in Neural NLI
In the interest of interpreting neural NLI models and their reasoning strategies, we carry out a systematic probing study which investigates whether these models capture the crucial semantic features central to natural logic: \emph{monotonicity} and \emph{concept inclusion}. Correctly identifying valid inferences in \emph{downward-monotone contexts} is a known stumbling block for NLI performance, subsuming linguistic phenomena such as negation scope and generalized quantifiers. To understand this difficulty, we emphasize monotonicity as a property of a \emph{context} and examine the extent to which models capture monotonicity information in the contextual embeddings which are intermediate to their decision making process. Drawing on the recent advancement of the probing paradigm, we compare the presence of monotonicity features across various models. We find that monotonicity information is notably weak in the representations of popular NLI models which achieve high scores on benchmarks, and observe that previous improvements to these models based on fine-tuning strategies have introduced stronger monotonicity features together with their improved performance on challenge sets.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Decision MakingNegationvalidSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Decomposing Natural Logic Inferences in Neural NLI
In the interest of interpreting neural NLI models and their reasoning strategies, we carry out a systematic probing study which investigates whether these models capture the crucial semantic features central to natural l…
Decision MakingNegationvalidMonotonic Inference for Underspecified Episodic Logic
We present a method of making natural logic inferences from Unscoped Logical Form of Episodic Logic. We establish a correspondence between inference rules of scope resolved Episodic Logic and the natural logic treatment …
Generating Discourse Inferences from Unscoped Episodic Logical Formulas
Abstract Unscoped episodic logical form (ULF) is a semantic representation capturing the predicate-argument structure of English within the episodic logic formalism in relation to the syntactic structure, while leaving s…
Do Neural Models Learn Systematicity of Monotonicity Inference in Natural Language?
Despite the success of language models using neural networks, it remains unclear to what extent neural models have the generalization ability to perform inferences. In this paper, we introduce a method for evaluating whe…
A (Mostly) Symbolic System for Monotonic Inference with Unscoped Episodic Logical Forms
We implement the formalization of natural logic-like monotonic inference using Unscoped Episodic Logical Forms (ULFs) by Kim et al. (2020). We demonstrate this system’s capacity to handle a variety of challenging semanti…