Deepcode and Modulo-SK are Designed for Different Settings
We respond to [1] which claimed that "Modulo-SK scheme outperforms Deepcode [2]". We demonstrate that this statement is not true: the two schemes are designed and evaluated for entirely different settings. DeepCode is designed and evaluated for the AWGN channel with (potentially delayed) uncoded output feedback. Modulo-SK is evaluated on the AWGN channel with coded feedback and unit delay. [1] also claimed an implementation of Schalkwijk and Kailath (SK) [3] which was numerically stable for any number of information bits and iterations. However, we observe that while their implementation does marginally improve over ours, it also suffers from a fundamental issue with precision. Finally, we show that Deepcode dominates the optimized performance of SK, over a natural choice of parameterizations when the feedback is noisy.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Simple Modulo can Significantly Outperform Deep Learning-based Deepcode
Deepcode (H.Kim et al.2018) is a recently suggested Deep Learning-based scheme for communication over the AWGN channel with noisy feedback, claimed to be superior to all previous schemes in the literature. Deepcode's use…
Deep LearningDeepCodeProbe: Towards Understanding What Models Trained on Code Learn
Machine learning models trained on code and related artifacts offer valuable support for software maintenance but suffer from interpretability issues due to their complex internal variables. These concerns are particular…
Clone DetectionCode SummarizationComment GenerationDecision Making+1Practical Modulo Sampling: Mitigating High-Frequency Components
Recovering signals within limited dynamic range (DR) constraints remains a central challenge for analog-to-digital converters (ADCs). To prevent data loss, an ADCs DR typically must exceed that of the input signal. Modul…
QuantizationDeepCode: Open Agentic Coding
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have given rise to powerful coding agents, making it possible for code assistants to evolve into code engineers. However, existing methods still face significant challenges…
DeepCoder: Semi-parametric Variational Autoencoders for Automatic Facial Action Coding
Human face exhibits an inherent hierarchy in its representations (i.e., holistic facial expressions can be encoded via a set of facial action units (AUs) and their intensity). Variational (deep) auto-encoders (VAE) have …
Gaussian Processes