Differential Test Performance and Peer Effects
We use variation of test scores measuring closely related skills to isolate peer effects. The intuition for our identification strategy is that the difference in closely related scores eliminates factors common to the performance in either test while retaining idiosyncratic test specific variation. Common factors include unobserved teacher and group effects as well as test invariant ability and factors relevant for peer group formation. Peer effects work through idiosyncratic shocks which have the interpretation of individual and test specific ability or effort. We use education production functions as well as restrictions on the information content of unobserved test taking ability to formalize our approach. An important implication of our identifying assumptions is that we do not need to rely on randomized group assignment. We show that our model restrictions are sufficient for the formulation of linear and quadratic moment conditions that identify the peer effects parameter of interest. We use Project STAR data to empirically measure peer effects in kindergarten through third grade classes. We find evidence of highly significant peer effects with magnitudes that are at the lower end of the range of estimates found in the literature.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Testing for Peer Effects without Specifying the Network Structure
This paper proposes an Anderson-Rubin (AR) test for the presence of peer effects in panel data without the need to specify the network structure. The unrestricted model of our test is a linear panel data model of social …
validIdentification of Peer Effects with Miss-specified Peer Groups: Missing Data and Group Uncertainty
We consider identification of peer effects under peer group miss-specification. Two leading cases are missing data and peer group uncertainty. Missing data can take the form of some individuals being entirely absent from…
Are `Water Smart Landscapes' Contagious? An epidemic approach on networks to study peer effects
We test the existence of a neighborhood based peer effect around participation in an incentive based conservation program called `Water Smart Landscapes' (WSL) in the city of Las Vegas, Nevada. We use 15 years of geo-cod…
Balancing Efficiency and Equity in Classroom Assignment under Endogenous Peer Effects
This paper presents a three-step empirical framework for optimizing classroom assignments under endogenous peer effects, using data from the China Education Panel Survey (CEPS). We design \textit{PeerNN}, a neural networ…
counterfactualFairnessActive peer effects in residential photovoltaic adoption: evidence on impact drivers among potential and current adopters in Germany
While the importance of peer influences has been demonstrated in several studies, little is known about the underlying mechanisms of active peer effects in residential photovoltaic (PV) diffusion. Empirical evidence indi…
Decision Making