Do Smaller Language Models Answer Contextualised Questions Through Memorisation Or Generalisation?
A distinction is often drawn between a model's ability to predict a label for an evaluation sample that is directly memorised from highly similar training samples versus an ability to predict the label via some method of generalisation. In the context of using Language Models for question-answering, discussion continues to occur as to the extent to which questions are answered through memorisation. We consider this issue for questions that would ideally be answered through reasoning over an associated context. We propose a method of identifying evaluation samples for which it is very unlikely our model would have memorised the answers. Our method is based on semantic similarity of input tokens and label tokens between training and evaluation samples. We show that our method offers advantages upon some prior approaches in that it is able to surface evaluation-train pairs that have overlap in either contiguous or discontiguous sequences of tokens. We use this method to identify unmemorisable subsets of our evaluation datasets. We train two Language Models in a multitask fashion whereby the second model differs from the first only in that it has two additional datasets added to the training regime that are designed to impart simple numerical reasoning strategies of a sort known to improve performance on some of our evaluation datasets but not on others. We then show that there is performance improvement between the two models on the unmemorisable subsets of the evaluation datasets that were expected to benefit from the additional training datasets. Specifically, performance on unmemorisable subsets of two of our evaluation datasets, DROP and ROPES significantly improves by 9.0%, and 25.7% respectively while other evaluation datasets have no significant change in performance.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Question AnsweringSemantic SimilaritySemantic Textual SimilaritySimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Teaching Smaller Language Models To Generalise To Unseen Compositional Questions (Full Thesis)
Pretrained large Language Models (LLMs) are able to answer questions that are unlikely to have been encountered during training. However a diversity of potential applications exist in the broad domain of reasoning system…
RetrievalUnsupervised Natural Question Answering with a Small Model
The recent (2019-02) demonstration of the power of huge language models such as GPT-2 to memorise the answers to factoid questions raises questions about the extent to which knowledge is being embedded directly within th…
Language ModelingLanguage ModellingmodelQuestion AnsweringEnhancing Unsupervised Sentence Similarity Methods with Deep Contextualised Word Representations
Calculating Semantic Textual Similarity (STS) plays a significant role in many applications such as question answering, document summarisation, information retrieval and information extraction. All modern state of the ar…
Contextualised Word RepresentationsInformation RetrievalQuestion AnsweringRetrieval+5Can Language Models Analyze Data? Evaluating Large Language Models for Question Answering over Datasets
This paper investigates the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) in answering questions over datasets. We examine their performance in two scenarios: (a) directly answering questions given a dataset file as inpu…
Question AnsweringTeaching Smaller Language Models To Generalise To Unseen Compositional Questions
We equip a smaller Language Model to generalise to answering challenging compositional questions that have not been seen in training. To do so we propose a combination of multitask supervised pretraining on up to 93 task…
ARCInformation RetrievalLanguage ModelingLanguage Modelling+3