Does the Performance of Text-to-Image Retrieval Models Generalize Beyond Captions-as-a-Query?
Text-image retrieval (T2I) refers to the task of recovering all images relevant to a keyword query. Popular datasets for text-image retrieval, such as Flickr30k, VG, or MS-COCO, utilize annotated image captions, e.g., “a man playing with a kid”, as a surrogate for queries. With such surrogate queries, current multi-modal machine learning models, such as CLIP or BLIP, perform remarkably well. The main reason is the descriptive nature of captions, which detail the content of an image. Yet, T2I queries go beyond the mere descriptions in image-caption pairs. Thus, these datasets are ill-suited to test methods on more abstract or conceptual queries, e.g., “family vacations”. In such queries, the image content is implied rather than explicitly described. In this paper, we replicate the T2I results on descriptive queries and generalize them to conceptual queries. To this end, we perform new experiments on a novel T2I benchmark for the task of conceptual query answering, called ConQA. ConQA comprises 30 descriptive and 50 conceptual queries on 43k images with more than 100 manually annotated images per query. Our results on established measures show that both large pretrained models (e.g., CLIP, BLIP, and BLIP2) and small models (e.g., SGRAF and NAAF), perform up to 4x better on descriptive rather than conceptual queries. We also find that the models perform better on queries with more than 6 keywords as in MS-COCO captions.
Code (1)
Tasks
DescriptiveImage CaptioningImage RetrievalRetrievalMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Do Cross Modal Systems Leverage Semantic Relationships?
Current cross-modal retrieval systems are evaluated using R@K measure which does not leverage semantic relationships rather strictly follows the manually marked image text query pairs. Therefore, current systems do not g…
Cross-Modal RetrievalRetrievalSemantic SimilaritySemantic Textual SimilarityGeneralized Contrastive Learning for Universal Multimodal Retrieval
Despite their consistent performance improvements, cross-modal retrieval models (e.g., CLIP) show degraded performances with retrieving keys composed of fused image-text modality (e.g., Wikipedia pages with both images a…
Cross-Modal RetrievalContrastive LearningOpen Vocabulary Panoptic Segmentation With Retrieval Augmentation
Given an input image and set of class names, panoptic segmentation aims to label each pixel in an image with class labels and instance labels. In comparison, Open Vocabulary Panoptic Segmentation aims to facilitate the s…
Open Vocabulary Panoptic SegmentationNearest Neighbor Normalization Improves Multimodal Retrieval
Multimodal models leverage large-scale pre-training to achieve strong but still imperfect performance on tasks such as image captioning, visual question answering, and cross-modal retrieval. In this paper, we present a s…
Cross-Modal RetrievalImage CaptioningImage RetrievalImage-text Retrieval+4Where Does the Performance Improvement Come From? -- A Reproducibility Concern about Image-Text Retrieval
This article aims to provide the information retrieval community with some reflections on recent advances in retrieval learning by analyzing the reproducibility of image-text retrieval models. Due to the increase of mult…
Image-text RetrievalInformation RetrievalRetrievalText Retrieval