Empirical Characterization of Inference-Time Elicited Probability Transformations in Large Language Models
Large language models increasingly rely on inference-time procedures such as chain-of-thought reasoning, self-refinement, retrieval augmentation, and verifier-guided revision, yet the structure of elicited probability transformations under these procedures remains poorly understood. We study externally elicited probability assignments over candidate answers and observe recurring approximate log-ratio relationships: \[ \log \tilde q_t(i) = α_t \left( \log q_t(i) + \log b_t(i) \right) + c_t, \] where $q_t$ and $\tilde q_t$ are pre- and post-elicitation probabilities, $b_t$ is an externally constructed evidence signal, and $α_t$ is an empirical descriptor of the prompting configuration. Across 4,975 reasoning problems from GPQA Diamond, TheoremQA, MMLU-Pro, and ARC-Challenge, evaluated on multiple instruction-tuned model families, we observe approximate log-ratio relationships with mean $R^2 \approx 0.76$ over about $1.3 \times 10^5$ candidate-level observations. Coefficients vary across elicitation settings, but qualitatively similar relationships persist across evaluated conditions. Robustness analyses using alternative statistical representations, prompting configurations, held-out evaluation, and token-level log-probabilities suggest that the observed structure is not tied to one prompting procedure or probability estimation method. The main contribution is not the algebraic form itself, which is related to generalized Bayesian updating and probability-transformation frameworks, but the empirical observation that diverse inference-time prompting pipelines repeatedly exhibit reproducible log-ratio structure under controlled conditions. The framework provides a protocol-sensitive perspective for analyzing calibration, evidence amplification, uncertainty propagation, and interaction sensitivity in inference-time LLM pipelines.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Hypothesis-only Biases in Large Language Model-Elicited Natural Language Inference
We test whether replacing crowdsource workers with LLMs to write Natural Language Inference (NLI) hypotheses similarly results in annotation artifacts. We recreate a portion of the Stanford NLI corpus using GPT-4, Llama-…
Language ModelingLanguage ModellingLarge Language ModelNatural Language InferenceWhen Agents Say One Thing and Do Another: Validating Elicited Beliefs from LLMs
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in high-stakes settings where good decisions require forming beliefs over the probability of unknown outcomes. However, it is unclear whether LLMs act as if they hol…
Expert Opinion Elicitation for Assisting Deep Learning based Lyme Disease Classifier with Patient Data
Diagnosing erythema migrans (EM) skin lesion, the most common early symptom of Lyme disease using deep learning techniques can be effective to prevent long-term complications. Existing works on deep learning based EM rec…
Deep LearningDensity EstimationJoint Probability Trees
We introduce Joint Probability Trees (JPT), a novel approach that makes learning of and reasoning about joint probability distributions tractable for practical applications. JPTs support both symbolic and subsymbolic var…
Exoplanet Characterization using Conditional Invertible Neural Networks
The characterization of an exoplanet's interior is an inverse problem, which requires statistical methods such as Bayesian inference in order to be solved. Current methods employ Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling …
Bayesian Inference