Estimating prediction error for complex samples
With a growing interest in using non-representative samples to train prediction models for numerous outcomes it is necessary to account for the sampling design that gives rise to the data in order to assess the generalized predictive utility of a proposed prediction rule. After learning a prediction rule based on a non-uniform sample, it is of interest to estimate the rule's error rate when applied to unobserved members of the population. Efron (1986) proposed a general class of covariance penalty inflated prediction error estimators that assume the available training data are representative of the target population for which the prediction rule is to be applied. We extend Efron's estimator to the complex sample context by incorporating Horvitz-Thompson sampling weights and show that it is consistent for the true generalization error rate when applied to the underlying superpopulation. The resulting Horvitz-Thompson-Efron (HTE) estimator is equivalent to dAIC, a recent extension of AIC to survey sampling data, but is more widely applicable. The proposed methodology is assessed with simulations and is applied to models predicting renal function obtained from the large-scale NHANES survey.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
PredictionSurveySurvey SamplingThompson SamplingSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
How Many Samples are Needed to Estimate a Convolutional Neural Network?
A widespread folklore for explaining the success of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) is that CNNs use a more compact representation than the Fully-connected Neural Network (FNN) and thus require fewer training sample…
LEMMAEstimating Learnability in the Sublinear Data Regime
We consider the problem of estimating how well a model class is capable of fitting a distribution of labeled data. We show that it is often possible to accurately estimate this "learnability" even when given an amount of…
Binary ClassificationGenerative Conformal Prediction with Vectorized Non-Conformity Scores
Conformal prediction (CP) provides model-agnostic uncertainty quantification with guaranteed coverage, but conventional methods often produce overly conservative uncertainty sets, especially in multi-dimensional settings…
Autonomous DrivingConformal PredictionDecision MakingMedical Diagnosis+3Estimating the Fundamental Limits is Easier than Achieving the Fundamental Limits
We show through case studies that it is easier to estimate the fundamental limits of data processing than to construct explicit algorithms to achieve those limits. Focusing on binary classification, data compression, and…
Binary ClassificationData CompressionGeneral ClassificationSoftware Defect Prediction Based On Deep Learning Models: Performance Study
In recent years, defect prediction, one of the major software engineering problems, has been in the focus of researchers since it has a pivotal role in estimating software errors and faulty modules. Researchers with the …
Deep LearningPrediction