Estimating the loss of economic predictability from aggregating firm-level production networks
To estimate the reaction of economies to political interventions or external disturbances, input-output (IO) tables -- constructed by aggregating data into industrial sectors -- are extensively used. However, economic growth, robustness, and resilience crucially depend on the detailed structure of non-aggregated firm-level production networks (FPNs). Due to non-availability of data little is known about how much aggregated sector-based and detailed firm-level-based model-predictions differ. Using a nearly complete nationwide FPN, containing 243,399 Hungarian firms with 1,104,141 supplier-buyer-relations we self-consistently compare production losses on the aggregated industry-level production network (IPN) and the granular FPN. For this we model the propagation of shocks of the same size on both, the IPN and FPN, where the latter captures relevant heterogeneities within industries. In a COVID-19 inspired scenario we model the shock based on detailed firm-level data during the early pandemic. We find that using IPNs instead of FPNs leads to errors up to 37% in the estimation of economic losses, demonstrating a natural limitation of industry-level IO-models in predicting economic outcomes. We ascribe the large discrepancy to the significant heterogeneity of firms within industries: we find that firms within one sector only sell 23.5% to and buy 19.3% from the same industries on average, emphasizing the strong limitations of industrial sectors for representing the firms they include. Similar error-levels are expected when estimating economic growth, CO2 emissions, and the impact of policy interventions with industry-level IO models. Granular data is key for reasonable predictions of dynamical economic systems.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Methods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
150 Years of Return Predictability Around the World: A Holistic View
Using new annual data of 16 developed countries across bond, equity, and housing markets, I study the return predictability using the payout-price ratios, i.e., coupon price, dividend price, and rent price. None of the 4…
Mixed-Effects Methods for Search and Matching Research
We study mixed-effects methods for estimating equations containing person and firm effects. In economics such models are usually estimated using fixed-effects methods. Recent enhancements to those fixed-effects methods i…
Estimating high-dimensional Markov-switching VARs
Maximum likelihood estimation of large Markov-switching vector autoregressions (MS-VARs) can be challenging or infeasible due to parameter proliferation. To accommodate situations where dimensionality may be of comparabl…
Variable SelectionVocal Bursts Intensity PredictionFirm-level supply chains to minimize unemployment and economic losses in rapid decarbonization scenarios
Urgently needed carbon emissions reductions might lead to strict command-and-control decarbonization strategies with potentially negative economic consequences. Analysing the entire firm-level production network of a Eur…
Predicting Realized Variance Out of Sample: Can Anything Beat The Benchmark?
The discrepancy between realized volatility and the market's view of volatility has been known to predict individual equity options at the monthly horizon. It is not clear how this predictability depends on a forecast's …