Evaluating Search System Explainability with Psychometrics and Crowdsourcing
As information retrieval (IR) systems, such as search engines and conversational agents, become ubiquitous in various domains, the need for transparent and explainable systems grows to ensure accountability, fairness, and unbiased results. Despite recent advances in explainable AI and IR techniques, there is no consensus on the definition of explainability. Existing approaches often treat it as a singular notion, disregarding the multidimensional definition postulated in the literature. In this paper, we use psychometrics and crowdsourcing to identify human-centered factors of explainability in Web search systems and introduce SSE (Search System Explainability), an evaluation metric for explainable IR (XIR) search systems. In a crowdsourced user study, we demonstrate SSE's ability to distinguish between explainable and non-explainable systems, showing that systems with higher scores indeed indicate greater interpretability. We hope that aside from these concrete contributions to XIR, this line of work will serve as a blueprint for similar explainability evaluation efforts in other domains of machine learning and natural language processing.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
FairnessInformation RetrievalRecommendation SystemsRetrievalSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
AI Psychometrics: Evaluating the Psychological Reasoning of Large Language Models with Psychometric Validities
The immense number of parameters and deep neural networks make large language models (LLMs) rival the complexity of human brains, which also makes them opaque ``black box'' systems that are challenging to evaluate and in…
Evaluating General-Purpose AI with Psychometrics
Comprehensive and accurate evaluation of general-purpose AI systems such as large language models allows for effective mitigation of their risks and deepened understanding of their capabilities. Current evaluation method…
Large Language Model Psychometrics: A Systematic Review of Evaluation, Validation, and Enhancement
The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has outpaced traditional evaluation methodologies. It presents novel challenges, such as measuring human-like psychological constructs, navigating beyond static and t…
BenchmarkingLanguage ModelingLanguage ModellingLarge Language ModelThe Unsampled Truth: Psychometrics in SLMs Measure Prompt Artifacts, Not Psychological Constructs
When prompting SLMs for psychometric assessments, researchers assume the outputs reflect semantic reasoning. We evaluate this premise across 13 open-weights models (0.6B to 14B parameters) using a prompt variation framew…
SSE: A Metric for Evaluating Search System Explainability
Explainable Information Retrieval (XIR) is a growing research area focused on enhancing transparency and trustworthiness of the complex decision-making processes taking place in modern information retrieval systems. Whil…
Decision MakingInformation RetrievalRetrieval