Filter bubbles and affective polarization in user-personalized large language model outputs
Echoing the history of search engines and social media content rankings, the advent of large language models (LLMs) has led to a push for increased personalization of model outputs to individual users. In the past, personalized recommendations and ranking systems have been linked to the development of filter bubbles (serving content that may confirm a user's existing biases) and affective polarization (strong negative sentiment towards those with differing views). In this work, we explore how prompting a leading large language model, ChatGPT-3.5, with a user's political affiliation prior to asking factual questions about public figures and organizations leads to differing results. We observe that left-leaning users tend to receive more positive statements about left-leaning political figures and media outlets, while right-leaning users see more positive statements about right-leaning entities. This pattern holds across presidential candidates, members of the U.S. Senate, and media organizations with ratings from AllSides. When qualitatively evaluating some of these outputs, there is evidence that particular facts are included or excluded based on the user's political affiliation. These results illustrate that personalizing LLMs based on user demographics carry the same risks of affective polarization and filter bubbles that have been seen in other personalized internet technologies. This ``failure mode" should be monitored closely as there are more attempts to monetize and personalize these models.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Language ModelingLanguage ModellingLarge Language ModelSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Quantifying the Potential to Escape Filter Bubbles: A Behavior-Aware Measure via Contrastive Simulation
Nowadays, recommendation systems have become crucial to online platforms, shaping user exposure by accurate preference modeling. However, such an exposure strategy can also reinforce users' existing preferences, leading …
Recommendation SystemsMitigating Filter Bubbles within Deep Recommender Systems
Recommender systems, which offer personalized suggestions to users, power many of today's social media, e-commerce and entertainment. However, these systems have been known to intellectually isolate users from a variety …
Recommendation SystemsDesigning Recommender Systems to Depolarize
Polarization is implicated in the erosion of democracy and the progression to violence, which makes the polarization properties of large algorithmic content selection systems (recommender systems) a matter of concern for…
DiversityRecommendation SystemsEvolution of Filter Bubbles and Polarization in News Recommendation
Recent work in news recommendation has demonstrated that recommenders can over-expose users to articles that support their pre-existing opinions. However, most existing work focuses on a static setting or over a short-ti…
ArticlesNews RecommendationRecommendation SystemsSocially-Aware Recommender Systems Mitigate Opinion Clusterization
Recommender systems shape online interactions by matching users with creators content to maximize engagement. Creators, in turn, adapt their content to align with users preferences and enhance their popularity. At the sa…