Finding the Ground-Truth from Multiple Labellers: Why Parameters of the Task Matter
Employing multiple workers to label data for machine learning models has become increasingly important in recent years with greater demand to collect huge volumes of labelled data to train complex models while mitigating the risk of incorrect and noisy labelling. Whether it is large scale data gathering on popular crowd-sourcing platforms or smaller sets of workers in high-expertise labelling exercises, there are various methods recommended to gather a consensus from employed workers and establish ground-truth labels. However, there is very little research on how the various parameters of a labelling task can impact said methods. These parameters include the number of workers, worker expertise, number of labels in a taxonomy and sample size. In this paper, Majority Vote, CrowdTruth and Binomial Expectation Maximisation are investigated against the permutations of these parameters in order to provide better understanding of the parameter settings to give an advantage in ground-truth inference. Findings show that both Expectation Maximisation and CrowdTruth are only likely to give an advantage over majority vote under certain parameter conditions, while there are many cases where the methods can be shown to have no major impact. Guidance is given as to what parameters methods work best under, while the experimental framework provides a way of testing other established methods and also testing new methods that can attempt to provide advantageous performance where the methods in this paper did not. A greater level of understanding regarding optimal crowd-sourcing parameters is also achieved.
Code (1)
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Deep Supervised Summarization: Algorithm and Application to Learning Instructions
We address the problem of finding representative points of datasets by learning from multiple datasets and their ground-truth summaries. We develop a supervised subset selection framework, based on the facility location …
Representation LearningA Streaming Algorithm for Crowdsourced Data Classification
We propose a streaming algorithm for the binary classification of data based on crowdsourcing. The algorithm learns the competence of each labeller by comparing her labels to those of other labellers on the same tasks an…
Binary ClassificationClassificationGeneral ClassificationLearning to Complement with Multiple Humans
Real-world image classification tasks tend to be complex, where expert labellers are sometimes unsure about the classes present in the images, leading to the issue of learning with noisy labels (LNL). The ill-posedness o…
image-classificationImage ClassificationLearning with noisy labelsCoALT: A Software for Comparing Automatic Labelling Tools
Speech-text alignment tools are frequently used in speech technology and research. In this paper, we propose a GPL software CoALT (Comparing Automatic Labelling Tools) for comparing two automatic labellers or two speech-…
Speech RecognitionSpeech SynthesisPhrase-grounded Fact-checking for Automatically Generated Chest X-ray Reports
With the emergence of large-scale vision language models (VLM), it is now possible to produce realistic-looking radiology reports for chest X-ray images. However, their clinical translation has been hampered by the factu…