Improving Selective Classification with Pairwise Queries for Binary Classification
In selective classification, a model predicts the labels of data samples where it is confident, and abstains from predicting labels for samples on which it is not confident. The rejected samples are often labeled by an expert, which is expensive. The budget for the expert is best utilized when the model has low error on non-rejected samples. However, the estimate of a model's confidence might be inconsistent with the model's predictions, which can lead to high error on non-rejected points. Such situations can readily occur in in-context binary classification by LLMs. To remedy this, we propose making additional pairwise queries to the same model. These pairwise queries can detect high-error samples and be incorporated into selective classification techniques to reduce the error on non-rejected samples. Theoretically, we establish the conditions under which a simple algorithm using pairwise queries outperforms an inconsistent confidence estimate. We support this insight through extensive experiments for $1$ synthetic and $4$ in-context learning-based real binary classification datasets. In all these cases, we show that our algorithms, using pairwise queries, obtain a better accuracy-cost tradeoff than using only the raw confidence estimates, for instance, the LLM's next-token logits.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Binary ClassificationSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Trading via Selective Classification
A binary classifier that tries to predict if the price of an asset will increase or decrease naturally gives rise to a trading strategy that follows the prediction and thus always has a position in the market. Selective …
ClassificationPositionPointwise Binary Classification with Pairwise Confidence Comparisons
To alleviate the data requirement for training effective binary classifiers in binary classification, many weakly supervised learning settings have been proposed. Among them, some consider using pairwise but not pointwis…
Binary ClassificationClassificationGeneral ClassificationWeakly-supervised LearningBinary Self-Selective Voting Rules
This paper introduces a novel binary stability property for voting rules-called binary self-selectivity-by which a society considering whether to replace its voting rule using itself in pairwise elections will choose not…
Multi-Classification using One-versus-One Deep Learning Strategy with Joint Probability Estimates
The One-versus-One (OvO) strategy is an approach of multi-classification models which focuses on training binary classifiers between each pair of classes. While the OvO strategy takes advantage of balanced training data,…
ClassificationImage Aesthetic Assessment Based on Pairwise Comparison A Unified Approach to Score Regression, Binary Classification, and Personalization
We propose a unified approach to three tasks of aesthetic score regression, binary aesthetic classification, and personalized aesthetics. First, we develop a comparator to estimate the ratio of aesthetic scores for two i…
Binary ClassificationClassificationGeneral Classificationregression