Measuring CLEVRness: Black-box Testing of Visual Reasoning Models
How to measure the reasoning capabilities of intelligence systems? Visual question answering provides a convenient framework for testing the model's abilities by interrogating the model through questions about the scene. However, despite the score of various visual QA datasets and architectures, which sometimes yield even a super-human performance, the question of whether those architectures can do reasoning remains open. To answer such a question, we extend the visual question answering framework and propose the following behavioral test in the form of a two-player game. We consider black-box neural models of CLEVR. Those models are trained on a diagnostic dataset benchmarking reasoning. Next, we train an adversarial player that re-configures the scene to fool the CLEVR model. We show that CLEVR models, which otherwise may perform at a human level, can easily be fooled by our agent. Our results question one more time whether data-driven approaches can do reasoning without exploiting numerous biases that are often present in those datasets. Finally, we also propose a controlled experiment measuring the efficiency of such models to learn and perform reasoning.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
BenchmarkingDiagnosticQuestion AnsweringVisual Question AnsweringVisual Question Answering (VQA)Visual ReasoningMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Measuring CLEVRness: Blackbox testing of Visual Reasoning Models
How can we measure the reasoning capabilities of intelligence systems? Visual question answering provides a convenient framework for testing the model's abilities by interrogating the model through questions about the sc…
BenchmarkingDiagnosticQuestion AnsweringVisual Question Answering+2Thought Anchors: Which LLM Reasoning Steps Matter?
Reasoning large language models have recently achieved state-of-the-art performance in many fields. However, their long-form chain-of-thought reasoning creates interpretability challenges as each generated token depends …
counterfactualSentenceTesting Calibration in Nearly-Linear Time
In the recent literature on machine learning and decision making, calibration has emerged as a desirable and widely-studied statistical property of the outputs of binary prediction models. However, the algorithmic aspect…
Decision MakingHow to Determine the Preferred Image Distribution of a Black-Box Vision-Language Model?
Large foundation models have revolutionized the field, yet challenges remain in optimizing multi-modal models for specialized visual tasks. We propose a novel, generalizable methodology to identify preferred image distri…
In-Context LearningLanguage ModelingLanguage ModellingQuestion Answering+3PropTest: Automatic Property Testing for Improved Visual Programming
Visual Programming has recently emerged as an alternative to end-to-end black-box visual reasoning models. This type of method leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate the source code for an executable computer…
Question AnsweringReferring ExpressionReferring Expression ComprehensionVisual Question Answering+1