Multimodal Approaches for Visually-Rich Document Type Classification: A Comparative Analysis
Document type classification in visually rich documents remains challenging, as relevant information is distributed across textual, visual, and layout modalities. To capture this complexity, current approaches rely on diverse multimodal modeling strategies, resulting in heterogeneous architectures that complicate systematic comparison. This variability is also reflected in existing comparative studies, which often rely on heterogeneous evaluation setups, further complicating systematic comparison and making it difficult to assess progress. To address these limitations, this work provides a structured analysis of multimodal design strategies across transformer- and LLM-based architectures, combined with a controlled empirical comparison within a unified experimental framework. Specifically, four representative models (LayoutLMv3, Donut, Qwen3-VL-32B-Instruct, and Qwen3-32B) are evaluated on the RVL-CDIP benchmark to systematically analyze the contributions of text, image, and layout information for document type classification, with a particular focus on contrasting OCR-dependent and OCR-free approaches. The results show that specialized multimodal Transformers outperform LLM-based approaches on visually rich and layout-intensive documents. Image information contributes most strongly to reliable classification, while OCR-derived text provides useful but secondary support. These findings highlight that multimodal processing remains essential for documents with pronounced layout structure. Overall, the study provides a systematic basis for comparing multimodal architectures and offers practical guidance for selecting effective feature combinations and model designs for document type classification.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
XYLayoutLM: Towards Layout-Aware Multimodal Networks For Visually-Rich Document Understanding
Recently, various multimodal networks for Visually-Rich Document Understanding(VRDU) have been proposed, showing the promotion of transformers by integrating visual and layout information with the text embeddings. Howeve…
document understandingOptical Character Recognition (OCR)PositionOn Task-personalized Multimodal Few-shot Learning for Visually-rich Document Entity Retrieval
Visually-rich document entity retrieval (VDER), which extracts key information (e.g. date, address) from document images like invoices and receipts, has become an important topic in industrial NLP applications. The emerg…
Contrastive LearningEntity RetrievalFew-Shot LearningMeta-Learning+1Multimodal Graph RAG for Long-range Visually Rich Document Understanding
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) are widely applied to visual document understanding. However, comprehending long documents remains an issue by the limited context window. Though recent multimodal retrieval-augme…
Visual Question AnsweringLayoutXLM: Multimodal Pre-training for Multilingual Visually-rich Document Understanding
Multimodal pre-training with text, layout, and image has achieved SOTA performance for visually-rich document understanding tasks recently, which demonstrates the great potential for joint learning across different modal…
Document Image Classificationdocument understandingFormKey-value Pair ExtractionMarkupLM: Pre-training of Text and Markup Language for Visually-rich Document Understanding
Multimodal pre-training with text, layout, and image has made significant progress for Visually Rich Document Understanding (VRDU), especially the fixed-layout documents such as scanned document images. While, there are …
document understanding