Not even wrong: The spurious link between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning
Resolving the relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning has been one of the central goals of modern ecology. Early debates about the relationship were finally resolved with the advent of a statistical partitioning scheme that decomposed the biodiversity effect into a "selection" effect and a "complementarity" effect. We prove that both the biodiversity effect and its statistical decomposition into selection and complementarity are fundamentally flawed because these methods use a na\"ive null expectation based on neutrality, likely leading to an overestimate of the net biodiversity effect, and they fail to account for the nonlinear abundance-ecosystem functioning relationships observed in nature. Furthermore, under such nonlinearity no statistical scheme can be devised to partition the biodiversity effects. We also present an alternative metric providing a more reasonable estimate of biodiversity effect. Our results suggest that all studies conducted since the early 1990s likely overestimated the positive effects of biodiversity on ecosystem functioning.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Enforcing Consistency in Weakly Supervised Semantic Parsing
The predominant challenge in weakly supervised semantic parsing is that of spurious programs that evaluate to correct answers for the wrong reasons. Prior work uses elaborate search strategies to mitigate the prevalence …
Semantic ParsingVisual ReasoningThe Impact of Downgrading Protected Areas (PAD) on Biodiversity
We quantitatively assess the impacts of Downgrading Protected Areas (PAD) on biodiversity in the U.S.. Results show that PAD events significantly reduce biodiversity. The proximity to PAD events decreases the biodiversit…
Not even wrong: Reply to Wagg et al
We demonstrate that the issues described in the Wagg et al. (2019) Comment on our paper (Pillai and Gouhier, 2019) are all due to misunderstandings about the implications of pairwise effects, the nature of the null basel…
DiversityA metric for tradable biodiversity credits linked to the Living Planet Index and global species conservation
Difficulties identifying appropriate biodiversity impact metrics remain a major barrier to inclusion of biodiversity considerations in environmentally responsible investment. We propose and analyse a simple science-based…
Neutral phylogenetic models and their role in tree-based biodiversity measures
A wide variety of stochastic models of cladogenesis (based on speciation and extinction) lead to an identical distribution on phylogenetic tree shapes once the edge lengths are ignored. By contrast, the distribution of t…
Diversity