paper-with-me

홈 › Papers

On the Equivalence between Logic Programming and SETAF

2024-07-08 · João Alcântara, Renan Cordeiro, Samy Sá

A framework with sets of attacking arguments (SETAF) is an extension of the well-known Dung's Abstract Argumentation Frameworks (AAFs) that allows joint attacks on arguments. In this paper, we provide a translation from Normal Logic Programs (NLPs) to SETAFs and vice versa, from SETAFs to NLPs. We show that there is pairwise equivalence between their semantics, including the equivalence between L-stable and semi-stable semantics. Furthermore, for a class of NLPs called Redundancy-Free Atomic Logic Programs (RFALPs), there is also a structural equivalence as these back-and-forth translations are each other's inverse. Then, we show that RFALPs are as expressive as NLPs by transforming any NLP into an equivalent RFALP through a series of program transformations already known in the literature. We also show that these program transformations are confluent, meaning that every NLP will be transformed into a unique RFALP. The results presented in this paper enhance our understanding that NLPs and SETAFs are essentially the same formalism. Under consideration in Theory and Practice of Logic Programming (TPLP).

📄 PDF Abstract BibTeX arXiv:2407.05538

Code (0)

등록된 구현이 없습니다.

Tasks

Abstract Argumentation

Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반

On Strong Equivalence Notions in Logic Programming and Abstract Argumentation

2026-05-14 · Giovanni Buraglio, Wolfgang Dvorak, Stefan Woltran arxiv

Strong equivalence between knowledge bases ensures the possibility of replacing one with the other without affecting reasoning outcomes, in any given context. This makes it a crucial property in nonmonotonic formalisms. …

Strong Equivalence in Answer Set Programming with Constraints

2025-02-06 · Pedro Cabalar, Jorge Fandinno, Torsten Schaub, Philipp Wanko

We investigate the concept of strong equivalence within the extended framework of Answer Set Programming with constraints. Two groups of rules are considered strongly equivalent if, informally speaking, they have the sam…

Translation

On the Strong Equivalences of LPMLN Programs

2019-09-18 · Bin Wang, Jun Shen, Shutao Zhang, Zhizheng Zhang

By incorporating the methods of Answer Set Programming (ASP) and Markov Logic Networks (MLN), LPMLN becomes a powerful tool for non-monotonic, inconsistent and uncertain knowledge representation and reasoning. To facilit…

Expressiveness of SETAFs and Support-Free ADFs under 3-valued Semantics

2020-07-07 · Wolfgang Dvořák, Atefeh Keshavarzi Zafarghandi, Stefan Woltran

Generalizing the attack structure in argumentation frameworks (AFs) has been studied in different ways. Most prominently, the binary attack relation of Dung frameworks has been extended to the notion of collective attack…

Relation

Strong Equivalence and Program Structure in Arguing Essential Equivalence between Logic Programs

2019-01-26 · Yuliya Lierler

Answer set programming is a prominent declarative programming paradigm used in formulating combinatorial search problems and implementing different knowledge representation formalisms. Frequently, several related and yet…