Performance Metrics for Probabilistic Ordinal Classifiers
Ordinal classification models assign higher penalties to predictions further away from the true class. As a result, they are appropriate for relevant diagnostic tasks like disease progression prediction or medical image grading. The consensus for assessing their categorical predictions dictates the use of distance-sensitive metrics like the Quadratic-Weighted Kappa score or the Expected Cost. However, there has been little discussion regarding how to measure performance of probabilistic predictions for ordinal classifiers. In conventional classification, common measures for probabilistic predictions are Proper Scoring Rules (PSR) like the Brier score, or Calibration Errors like the ECE, yet these are not optimal choices for ordinal classification. A PSR named Ranked Probability Score (RPS), widely popular in the forecasting field, is more suitable for this task, but it has received no attention in the image analysis community. This paper advocates the use of the RPS for image grading tasks. In addition, we demonstrate a counter-intuitive and questionable behavior of this score, and propose a simple fix for it. Comprehensive experiments on four large-scale biomedical image grading problems over three different datasets show that the RPS is a more suitable performance metric for probabilistic ordinal predictions. Code to reproduce our experiments can be found at https://github.com/agaldran/prob_ord_metrics .
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
DiagnosticOrdinal ClassificationSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Convolutional and Deep Learning based techniques for Time Series Ordinal Classification
Time Series Classification (TSC) covers the supervised learning problem where input data is provided in the form of series of values observed through repeated measurements over time, and whose objective is to predict the…
BenchmarkingOrdinal ClassificationTime SeriesTime Series ClassificationConvolutional Ordinal Regression Forest for Image Ordinal Estimation
Image ordinal estimation is to predict the ordinal label of a given image, which can be categorized as an ordinal regression problem. Recent methods formulate an ordinal regression problem as a series of binary classific…
Age EstimationBinary ClassificationregressionLearning Probabilistic Ordinal Embeddings for Uncertainty-Aware Regression
Uncertainty is the only certainty there is. Modeling data uncertainty is essential for regression, especially in unconstrained settings. Traditionally the direct regression formulation is considered and the uncertainty i…
Aesthetics Quality AssessmentAge And Gender ClassificationAge EstimationHistorical Color Image Dating+1Splitting criteria for ordinal decision trees: an experimental study
Ordinal Classification (OC) is a machine learning field that addresses classification tasks where the labels exhibit a natural order. Unlike nominal classification, which treats all classes as equally distinct, OC takes …
ClassificationOrdinal ClassificationProbabilistic Deep Ordinal Regression Based on Gaussian Processes
With excellent representation power for complex data, deep neural networks (DNNs) based approaches are state-of-the-art for ordinal regression problem which aims to classify instances into ordinal categories. However, DN…
Age And Gender ClassificationAge EstimationGaussian ProcessesHistorical Color Image Dating+1