Precision versus Shrinkage: A Comparative Analysis of Covariance Estimation Methods for Portfolio Allocation
In this paper, we perform a comprehensive study of different covariance and precision matrix estimation methods in the context of minimum variance portfolio allocation. The set of models studied by us can be broadly categorized as: Gaussian Graphical Model (GGM) based methods, Shrinkage Methods, Thresholding and Random Matrix Theory (RMT) based methods. Among these, GGM methods estimate the precision matrix directly while the other approaches estimate the covariance matrix. We perform a synthetic experiment to study the network learning and sample complexity performance of GGM methods. Thereafter, we compare all the covariance and precision matrix estimation methods in terms of their predictive ability for daily, weekly and monthly horizons. We consider portfolio risk as an indicator of estimation error and employ it as a loss function for comparison of the methods under consideration. We find that GGM methods outperform shrinkage and other approaches. Our observations for the performance of GGM methods are consistent with the synthetic experiment. We also propose a new criterion for the hyperparameter tuning of GGM methods. Our tuning approach outperforms the existing methodology in the synthetic setup. We further perform an empirical experiment where we study the properties of the estimated precision matrix. The properties of the estimated precision matrices calculated using our tuning approach are in agreement with the algorithm performances observed in the synthetic experiment and the empirical experiment for predictive ability performance comparison. Apart from this, we perform another synthetic experiment which demonstrates the direct relation between estimation error of the precision matrix and portfolio risk.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
SCOPE: Spectral Concentration by Distributionally Robust Joint Covariance-Precision Estimation
We propose a distributionally robust formulation for simultaneously estimating the covariance matrix and the precision matrix of a random vector.The proposed model minimizes the worst-case weighted sum of the Frobenius l…
Asymptotic non-linear shrinkage and eigenvector overlap for weighted sample covariance
We compute asymptotic non-linear shrinkage formulas for covariance and precision matrix estimators for weighted sample covariances, and the joint sample-population eigenvector overlap distribution, in the spirit of Ledoi…
Forecasting Large Realized Covariance Matrices: The Benefits of Factor Models and Shrinkage
We propose a model to forecast large realized covariance matrices of returns, applying it to the constituents of the S\&P 500 daily. To address the curse of dimensionality, we decompose the return covariance matrix using…
Neural Nonlinear Shrinkage of Covariance Matrices for Minimum Variance Portfolio Optimization
This paper introduces a neural network-based nonlinear shrinkage estimator of covariance matrices for the purpose of minimum variance portfolio optimization. It is a hybrid approach that integrates statistical estimation…
Portfolio OptimizationAnalysis of a multi-target linear shrinkage covariance estimator
Multi-target linear shrinkage is an extension of the standard single-target linear shrinkage for covariance estimation. We combine several constant matrices - the targets - with the sample covariance matrix. We derive th…