ProcCtrlBench: Evaluating Process-Level Defects and Control Preservation in LLM Coding Agents
Existing benchmarks for LLM coding agents primarily evaluate final outcomes. While useful for measuring overall capability, these metrics provide limited visibility and often miss defects that arise during execution. We present ProcCtrlBench, a benchmark for execution-process evaluation in LLM coding agents. ProcCtrlBench organizes recurrent execution defects into a reusable ontology covering 11 defect types in 4 categories, and evaluates agent trajectories through standardized process evidence rather than final outcomes alone. To support comparison across heterogeneous agents, ProcCtrlBench standardizes raw logs into a unified trajectory representation and reports calibrated scorecards over process-level findings. In addition, ProcCtrlBench uses control preservation as a way to quantify execution-process quality, capturing whether execution remains interpretable, interruptible, correctable, reversible, and able to hand back authority when needed. We evaluate ProcCtrlBench on 200 cases sampled from three benchmarks: AndroidBench, TerminalBench, and SWE-bench-Verified. Results show that ProcCtrlBench can be instantiated with useful reliability, provides more stable semantics than direct thresholding, and reveals meaningful differences in execution quality that are often overlooked by conventional outcome-based evaluation.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Surface Defect Detection and Evaluation for Marine Vessels using Multi-Stage Deep Learning
Detecting and evaluating surface coating defects is important for marine vessel maintenance. Currently, the assessment is carried out manually by qualified inspectors using international standards and their own experienc…
Defect DetectionSegmentationSample-Centric Multi-Task Learning for Detection and Segmentation of Industrial Surface Defects
Industrial surface defect inspection for sample-wise quality control (QC) must simultaneously decide whether a given sample contains defects and localize those defects spatially. In real production lines, extreme foregro…
Multi-Task LearningA deep-learning-based approach for fast and robust steel surface defects classification
Automatic visual recognition of steel surface defects provides critical functionality to facilitate quality control of steel strip production. In this paper, we present a compact yet effective convolutional neural networ…
DiversityGeneral ClassificationDefect detection and segmentation in X-Ray images of magnesium alloy castings using the Detectron2 framework
New production techniques have emerged that have made it possible to produce metal parts with more complex shapes, making the quality control process more difficult. This implies that the visual and superficial analysis …
Defect Detectionobject-detectionObject DetectionSegmentationTexture-AD: An Anomaly Detection Dataset and Benchmark for Real Algorithm Development
Anomaly detection is a crucial process in industrial manufacturing and has made significant advancements recently. However, there is a large variance between the data used in the development and the data collected by the…
Anomaly DetectionDefect DetectionUnsupervised Anomaly Detection