Shortcutted Commonsense: Data Spuriousness in Deep Learning of Commonsense Reasoning
Commonsense is a quintessential human capacity that has been a core challenge to Artificial Intelligence since its inception. Impressive results in Natural Language Processing tasks, including in commonsense reasoning, have consistently been achieved with Transformer neural language models, even matching or surpassing human performance in some benchmarks. Recently, some of these advances have been called into question: so called data artifacts in the training data have been made evident as spurious correlations and shallow shortcuts that in some cases are leveraging these outstanding results. In this paper we seek to further pursue this analysis into the realm of commonsense related language processing tasks. We undertake a study on different prominent benchmarks that involve commonsense reasoning, along a number of key stress experiments, thus seeking to gain insight on whether the models are learning transferable generalizations intrinsic to the problem at stake or just taking advantage of incidental shortcuts in the data items. The results obtained indicate that most datasets experimented with are problematic, with models resorting to non-robust features and appearing not to be learning and generalizing towards the overall tasks intended to be conveyed or exemplified by the datasets.
Code (1)
Tasks
Deep LearningSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Leveraging Explicit Reasoning for Inference Integration in Commonsense-Augmented Dialogue Models
Open-domain dialogue systems need to grasp social commonsense to understand and respond effectively to human users. Commonsense-augmented dialogue models have been proposed that aim to infer commonsense knowledge from di…
Response GenerationSpecificityEvaluate Confidence Instead of Perplexity for Zero-shot Commonsense Reasoning
Commonsense reasoning is an appealing topic in natural language processing (NLP) as it plays a fundamental role in supporting the human-like actions of NLP systems. With large-scale language models as the backbone, unsup…
Language ModelingLanguage ModellingQuestion AnsweringUnsupervised Pre-trainingCommonsense Reasoning for Natural Language Processing
Commonsense knowledge, such as knowing that {``}bumping into people annoys them{''} or {``}rain makes the road slippery{''}, helps humans navigate everyday situations seamlessly. Yet, endowing machines with such human-li…
NavigateHybrid Reasoning Network for Video-based Commonsense Captioning
The task of video-based commonsense captioning aims to generate event-wise captions and meanwhile provide multiple commonsense descriptions (e.g., attribute, effect and intention) about the underlying event in the video.…
AttributeDecoderRetrieval Augmentation for Commonsense Reasoning: A Unified Approach
A common thread of retrieval-augmented methods in the existing literature focuses on retrieving encyclopedic knowledge, such as Wikipedia, which facilitates well-defined entity and relation spaces that can be modeled. Ho…
Retrieval