Simple Control Baselines for Evaluating Transfer Learning
Transfer learning has witnessed remarkable progress in recent years, for example, with the introduction of augmentation-based contrastive self-supervised learning methods. While a number of large-scale empirical studies on the transfer performance of such models have been conducted, there is not yet an agreed-upon set of control baselines, evaluation practices, and metrics to report, which often hinders a nuanced and calibrated understanding of the real efficacy of the methods. We share an evaluation standard that aims to quantify and communicate transfer learning performance in an informative and accessible setup. This is done by baking a number of simple yet critical control baselines in the evaluation method, particularly the blind-guess (quantifying the dataset bias), scratch-model (quantifying the architectural contribution), and maximal-supervision (quantifying the upper-bound). To demonstrate how the evaluation standard can be employed, we provide an example empirical study investigating a few basic questions about self-supervised learning. For example, using this standard, the study shows the effectiveness of existing self-supervised pre-training methods is skewed towards image classification tasks versus dense pixel-wise predictions. In general, we encourage using/reporting the suggested control baselines in evaluating transfer learning in order to gain a more meaningful and informative understanding.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
image-classificationImage ClassificationSelf-Supervised LearningTransfer LearningSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Pooling Attention: Evaluating Pretrained Transformer Embeddings for Deception Classification
This paper investigates fake news detection as a downstream evaluation of Transformer representations, benchmarking encoder-only and decoder-only pre-trained models (BERT, GPT-2, Transformer-XL) as frozen embedders paire…
Fake News DetectionAnticipatory Reinforcement Learning for Trajectory Tracking
Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) in industrial control often suffers from lag and overshoot due to purely reactive control based on the current tracking error. To achieve anticipatory control without high computational …
Reinforcement LearningDisentangling Linguistic Relatedness from Task Alignment in Cross-Lingual Transfer
We study cross-lingual transfer by fine-tuning seven large language models (4B--671B parameters) on Arabic and evaluating zero-shot reading comprehension on Semitic languages and non-Semitic controls. Across dense and Mi…
Cross-Lingual TransferReading ComprehensionTOKEN is a MASK: Few-shot Named Entity Recognition with Pre-trained Language Models
Transferring knowledge from one domain to another is of practical importance for many tasks in natural language processing, especially when the amount of available data in the target domain is limited. In this work, we p…
DescriptiveDomain Adaptationnamed-entity-recognitionNamed Entity Recognition+2MeMo: Meaningful, Modular Controllers via Noise Injection
Robots are often built from standardized assemblies, (e.g. arms, legs, or fingers), but each robot must be trained from scratch to control all the actuators of all the parts together. In this paper we demonstrate a new a…
Graph Neural Network