Teacher bias or measurement error?
In many countries, teachers' track recommendations are used to allocate students to secondary school tracks. Previous studies have shown that students from families with low socioeconomic status (SES) receive lower track recommendations than their peers from high SES families, conditional on standardized test scores. It is often argued that this indicates teacher bias. However, this claim is invalid in the presence of measurement error in test scores. We discuss how measurement error in test scores generates a biased coefficient of the conditional SES gap, and consider three empirical strategies to address this bias. Using administrative data from the Netherlands, we find that measurement error explains 35 to 43% of the conditional SES gap in track recommendations.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Applying the Lower-Biased Teacher Model in Semi-Supervised Object Detection
I present the Lower Biased Teacher model, an enhancement of the Unbiased Teacher model, specifically tailored for semi-supervised object detection tasks. The primary innovation of this model is the integration of a local…
Objectobject-detectionObject DetectionPseudo Label+1DualFete: Revisiting Teacher-Student Interactions from a Feedback Perspective for Semi-supervised Medical Image Segmentation
The teacher-student paradigm has emerged as a canonical framework in semi-supervised learning. When applied to medical image segmentation, the paradigm faces challenges due to inherent image ambiguities, making it partic…
Semi-supervised Medical Image SegmentationCoupled Calibration and Learning: Mitigating Teacher Bias in LLM Distillation without Target-Domain Reward Feedback
Large language model (LLM) distillation aims to transfer the capabilities of a powerful teacher to a smaller student. Direct imitation, however, can also transfer the teacher's systematic bias and errors. This challenge …
Double/Debiased CoCoLASSO of Treatment Effects with Mismeasured High-Dimensional Control Variables
We develop an estimator for treatment effects in high-dimensional settings with additive measurement error, a prevalent challenge in modern econometrics. We introduce the Double/Debiased Convex Conditioned LASSO (Double/…
EconometricsvalidMeasurement Error in Nutritional Epidemiology: A Survey
This article reviews bias-correction models for measurement error of exposure variables in the field of nutritional epidemiology. Measurement error usually attenuates estimated slope towards zero. Due to the influence of…
EpidemiologyregressionSurvey