Testing for differential abundance in compositional counts data, with application to microbiome studies
Identifying which taxa in our microbiota are associated with traits of interest is important for advancing science and health. However, the identification is challenging because the measured vector of taxa counts (by amplicon sequencing) is compositional, so a change in the abundance of one taxon in the microbiota induces a change in the number of sequenced counts across all taxa. The data is typically sparse, with zero counts present either due to biological variance or limited sequencing depth (technical zeros). For low abundance taxa, the chance for technical zeros is non-negligible. We show that existing methods designed to identify differential abundance for compositional data may have an inflated number of false positives due to improper handling of the zero counts. We introduce a novel non-parametric approach which provides valid inference even when the fraction of zero counts is substantial. Our approach uses a set of reference taxa that are non-differentially abundant, which can be estimated from the data or from outside information. We show the usefulness of our approach via simulations, as well as on three different data sets: a Crohn's disease study, the Human Microbiome Project, and an experiment with 'spiked-in' bacteria.
Code (3)
Tasks
validSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Group-wise normalization in differential abundance analysis of microbiome samples
A key challenge in differential abundance analysis of microbial samples is that the counts for each sample are compositional, resulting in biased comparisons of the absolute abundance across study groups. Normalization-b…
Bugs as Features (Part I): Concepts and Foundations for the Compositional Data Analysis of the Microbiome-Gut-Brain Axis
There has been a growing acknowledgement of the involvement of the gut microbiome - the collection of microbes that reside in our gut - in regulating our mood and behaviour. This phenomenon is referred to as the microbio…
DiversityThe Role of Interactivity in Local Differential Privacy
We study the power of interactivity in local differential privacy. First, we focus on the difference between fully interactive and sequentially interactive protocols. Sequentially interactive protocols may query users ad…
Two-sample testingInstrumental Variable Estimation for Compositional Treatments
Many scientific datasets are compositional in nature. Important biological examples include species abundances in ecology, cell-type compositions derived from single-cell sequencing data, and amplicon abundance data in m…
DiversityvalidPriv'IT: Private and Sample Efficient Identity Testing
We develop differentially private hypothesis testing methods for the small sample regime. Given a sample $\cal D$ from a categorical distribution $p$ over some domain $\Sigma$, an explicitly described distribution $q$ ov…
Two-sample testingVocal Bursts Type Prediction