The Hidden Costs of Translation Accuracy: Distillation, Quantization, and Environmental Impact
The rapid expansion of large language models (LLMs) has heightened concerns about their computational and environmental costs. This study investigates the trade-offs between translation quality and efficiency by comparing full-scale, distilled, and quantized models using machine translation as a case study. We evaluated performance on the Flores+ benchmark and through human judgments of conversational translations in French, Hindi, and Kannada. Our analysis revealed that the full 3.3B FP32 model, while achieving the highest BLEU scores, incurred the largest environmental footprint (~ 0.007-0.008 kg CO2 per run). The distilled 600M FP32 model reduced inference time by 71-78% and carbon emissions by 63-65% compared with the full model, with only minimal reductions in BLEU scores. Human evaluations further showed that even aggressive quantization (INT4) preserved high levels of accuracy and fluency, with differences between models generally minor. These findings demonstrate that model compression strategies can substantially reduce computational demands and environmental impact while maintaining competitive translation quality, though trade-offs are more pronounced in low-resource settings. We argue for evaluation frameworks that integrate efficiency and sustainability alongside accuracy as central dimensions of progress in NLP.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Machine TranslationModel CompressionSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
DQ-Whisper: Joint Distillation and Quantization for Efficient Multilingual Speech Recognition
As a popular multilingual and multitask pre-trained speech model, Whisper has the problem of curse of multilinguality. To enhance multilingual capabilities in small Whisper models, we propose DQ-Whisper, a novel joint di…
Knowledge DistillationQuantizationspeech-recognitionSpeech RecognitionModel compression via distillation and quantization
Deep neural networks (DNNs) continue to make significant advances, solving tasks from image classification to translation or reinforcement learning. One aspect of the field receiving considerable attention is efficiently…
image-classificationmodelModel CompressionQuantization+1Towards Full Utilization on Mask Task for Distilling PLMs into NMT
Owing to being well-performed in many natural language processing tasks, the application of pre-trained language models (PLMs) in neural machine translation (NMT) is widely concerned. Knowledge distillation (KD) is one o…
Knowledge DistillationMachine TranslationNMTTranslationLost in Distillation: A Case Study in Toxicity Modeling
In an era of increasingly large pre-trained language models, knowledge distillation is a powerful tool for transferring information from a large model to a smaller one. In particular, distillation is of tremendous benefi…
Knowledge DistillationPieces of Eight: 8-bit Neural Machine Translation
Neural machine translation has achieved levels of fluency and adequacy that would have been surprising a short time ago. Output quality is extremely relevant for industry purposes, however it is equally important to prod…
Machine TranslationQuantizationTranslation