Unexplainability of Artificial Intelligence Judgments in Kant's Perspective
Kant's Critique of Pure Reason, a major contribution to the history of epistemology, proposes a table of categories to elucidate the structure of the a priori principle of human judgment. The technology of artificial intelligence (AI), based on functionalism, claims to simulate or replicate human judgment. To assess this claim, it is necessary to study whether AI judgment possesses the characteristics of human judgment. This paper argues that AI judgments exhibit a form that cannot be understood in terms of the characteristics of human judgments according to Kant. Because the characteristics of judgment overlap, we can call this AI's uncertainty. Then, I show that concepts without physical intuitions are not easy to explain when their functions are shown through vision. Finally, I illustrate that even if AI makes sentences through subject and predicate in natural language, which are components of judgment, it is difficult to determine whether AI understands the concepts to the level humans can accept. This shows that it is questionable whether the explanation through natural language is reliable.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
A proposal for ethically traceable artificial intelligence
Although the problem of a critique of robotic behavior in near-unanimous agreement to human norms seems intractable, a starting point of such an ambition is a framework of the collection of knowledge a priori and experie…
Automated Kantian Ethics: A Faithful Implementation
As we grant artificial intelligence increasing power and independence in contexts like healthcare, policing, and driving, AI faces moral dilemmas but lacks the tools to solve them. Warnings from regulators, philosophers,…
EthicsOptimal Transport for $ε$-Contaminated Credal Sets: To the Memory of Sayan Mukherjee
We present generalized versions of Monge's and Kantorovich's optimal transport problems with the probabilities being transported replaced by lower probabilities. We show that, when the lower probabilities are the lower e…
FAIR: A Causal Framework for Accurately Inferring Judgments Reversals
Artificial intelligence researchers have made significant advances in legal intelligence in recent years. However, the existing studies have not focused on the important value embedded in judgments reversals, which limit…
Causal InferenceAn approximation-based approach versus an AI one for the study of CT images of abdominal aorta aneurysms
This study evaluates two approaches applied to computed tomography (CT) images of patients with abdominal aortic aneurysm: one deterministic, based on tools of Approximation Theory, and one based on Artificial Intelligen…
Computed Tomography (CT)