Utilitarianism on the front lines: COVID-19, public ethics, and the "hidden assumption" problem
How should we think of the preferences of citizens? Whereas self-optimal policy is relatively straightforward to produce, socially optimal policy often requires a more detailed examination. In this paper, we identify an issue that has received far too little attention in welfarist modelling of public policy, which we name the "hidden assumptions" problem. Hidden assumptions can be deceptive because they are not expressed explicitly and the social planner (e.g. a policy maker, a regulator, a legislator) may not give them the critical attention they need. We argue that ethical expertise has a direct role to play in public discourse because it is hard to adopt a position on major issues like public health policy or healthcare prioritisation without making contentious assumptions about population ethics. We then postulate that ethicists are best situated to critically evaluate these hidden assumptions, and can therefore play a vital role in public policy debates.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
EthicsSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
An Evaluation of GPT-4 on the ETHICS Dataset
This report summarizes a short study of the performance of GPT-4 on the ETHICS dataset. The ETHICS dataset consists of five sub-datasets covering different fields of ethics: Justice, Deontology, Virtue Ethics, Utilitaria…
EthicsUncovering Latent Human Wellbeing in Language Model Embeddings
Do language models implicitly learn a concept of human wellbeing? We explore this through the ETHICS Utilitarianism task, assessing if scaling enhances pretrained models' representations. Our initial finding reveals that…
EthicsLanguage ModelingLanguage Modellingmodel+1Formalizing Preference Utilitarianism in Physical World Models
Most ethical work is done at a low level of formality. This makes practical moral questions inaccessible to formal and natural sciences and can lead to misunderstandings in ethical discussion. In this paper, we use Bayes…
Bayesian InferenceEthicsNon-Additive Axiologies in Large Worlds
Is the overall value of a world just the sum of values contributed by each value-bearing entity in that world? Additively separable axiologies (like total utilitarianism, prioritarianism, and critical level views) say 'y…
EthicsSentiment Analysis and Topic Modeling for Public Perceptions of Air Travel: COVID Issues and Policy Amendments
Among many industries, air travel is impacted by the COVID pandemic. Airlines and airports rely on public sector information to enforce guidelines for ensuring health and safety of travelers. Such guidelines can be polic…
EthicsSentiment Analysis