What do we Really Know about State of the Art NER?
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a well researched NLP task and is widely used in real world NLP scenarios. NER research typically focuses on the creation of new ways of training NER, with relatively less emphasis on resources and evaluation. Further, state of the art (SOTA) NER models, trained on standard datasets, typically report only a single performance measure (F-score) and we don't really know how well they do for different entity types and genres of text, or how robust are they to new, unseen entities. In this paper, we perform a broad evaluation of NER using a popular dataset, that takes into consideration various text genres and sources constituting the dataset at hand. Additionally, we generate six new adversarial test sets through small perturbations in the original test set, replacing select entities while retaining the context. We also train and test our models on randomly generated train/dev/test splits followed by an experiment where the models are trained on a select set of genres but tested genres not seen in training. These comprehensive evaluation strategies were performed using three SOTA NER models. Based on our results, we recommend some useful reporting practices for NER researchers, that could help in providing a better understanding of a SOTA model's performance in future.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
named-entity-recognitionNamed Entity RecognitionNamed Entity Recognition (NER)NERSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
We Built a Fake News / Click Bait Filter: What Happened Next Will Blow Your Mind!
It is completely amazing! Fake news and {``}click baits{''} have totally invaded the cyberspace. Let us face it: everybody hates them for three simple reasons. Reason {\#}2 will absolutely amaze you. What these can achie…
Author ProfilingClickbait DetectionWord EmbeddingsWe Built a Fake News & Click-bait Filter: What Happened Next Will Blow Your Mind!
It is completely amazing! Fake news and click-baits have totally invaded the cyber space. Let us face it: everybody hates them for three simple reasons. Reason #2 will absolutely amaze you. What these can achieve at the …
Author ProfilingIntelligent Biohybrid Neurotechnologies: Are They Really What They Claim?
In the era of intelligent biohybrid neurotechnologies for brain repair, new fanciful terms are appearing in the scientific dictionary to define what has so far been unimaginable. As the emerging neurotechnologies are bec…
What Really is Deep Learning Doing?
Deep learning has achieved a great success in many areas, from computer vision to natural language processing, to game playing, and much more. Yet, what deep learning is really doing is still an open question. There are …
Deep LearningOpen-Ended Question AnsweringWhen Researchers Say Mental Model/Theory of Mind of AI, What Are They Really Talking About?
When researchers claim AI systems possess ToM or mental models, they are fundamentally discussing behavioral predictions and bias corrections rather than genuine mental states. This position paper argues that the current…