What the Harm? Quantifying the Tangible Impact of Gender Bias in Machine Translation with a Human-centered Study
Gender bias in machine translation (MT) is recognized as an issue that can harm people and society. And yet, advancements in the field rarely involve people, the final MT users, or inform how they might be impacted by biased technologies. Current evaluations are often restricted to automatic methods, which offer an opaque estimate of what the downstream impact of gender disparities might be. We conduct an extensive human-centered study to examine if and to what extent bias in MT brings harms with tangible costs, such as quality of service gaps across women and men. To this aim, we collect behavioral data from 90 participants, who post-edited MT outputs to ensure correct gender translation. Across multiple datasets, languages, and types of users, our study shows that feminine post-editing demands significantly more technical and temporal effort, also corresponding to higher financial costs. Existing bias measurements, however, fail to reflect the found disparities. Our findings advocate for human-centered approaches that can inform the societal impact of bias.
Code (1)
Tasks
Machine TranslationTranslationMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Context Matters: Auditing Gender Bias in T2I Generation through Risk-Tiered Use-Case Profiles
Text-to-image (T2I) generative models are increasingly used to produce content for education, media, and public-facing communication, and are starting to be integrated into higher-impact pipelines. Since generated images…
Gender PredictionQuantifying 60 Years of Gender Bias in Biomedical Research with Word Embeddings
Gender bias in biomedical research can have an adverse impact on the health of real people. For example, there is evidence that heart disease-related funded research generally focuses on men. Health disparities can form …
ArticlesWord EmbeddingsDiverse, but Divisive: LLMs Can Exaggerate Gender Differences in Opinion Related to Harms of Misinformation
The pervasive spread of misinformation and disinformation poses a significant threat to society. Professional fact-checkers play a key role in addressing this threat, but the vast scale of the problem forces them to prio…
Fact CheckingLanguage ModellingLarge Language ModelMisinformationMisgendering and Assuming Gender in Machine Translation when Working with Low-Resource Languages
This chapter focuses on gender-related errors in machine translation (MT) in the context of low-resource languages. We begin by explaining what low-resource languages are, examining the inseparable social and computation…
Machine TranslationMeasuring Machine Learning Harms from Stereotypes Requires Understanding Who Is Harmed by Which Errors in What Ways
As machine learning applications proliferate, we need an understanding of their potential for harm. However, current fairness metrics are rarely grounded in human psychological experiences of harm. Drawing on the social …
FairnessImage Retrieval