When Incentives and Nudges Meet: Promoting Budget Allocations for Undervalued Policies
Budget officers often assess public project proposals based on available financial support and expected outcomes. However, behavioral factors such as time discounting and psychological hesitation may lead to underinvestment in programs with delayed but significant benefits. This study investigates whether financial incentives and non-financial nudges can influence budgetary decisions in local governments. We conducted a nationwide mail-based survey experiment targeting budget officers in Japanese municipalities and received 490 valid responses. Using a 2*2 randomized design, we tested the independent and combined effects of a financial incentive (a 50% national subsidy) and a non-financial nudge (loss framing and peer information). All three treatments significantly increased assessed budget amounts compared to the control group. The largest effect appeared in the combination group (approximately 1.1 million JPY higher, p < .01). Both the financial incentive and the nudge independently increased assessments by approximately 650,000-670,000 JPY (p < .01). Notably, only the nudge raised the self-financed portion of the budget. These findings demonstrate how low-cost behavioral interventions can improve budget assessments for undervalued projects. As an application, we embedded the experiment in a case involving HPV vaccine promotion in Japan, but the approach can be broadly relevant to other public policy domains requiring forward-looking budget decisions.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
When do Default Nudges Work?
Nudging is a burgeoning topic in science and in policy, but evidence on the effectiveness of nudges among differentially-incentivized groups is lacking. This paper exploits regional variations in the roll-out of the Covi…
Social distancing in networks: A web-based interactive experiment
Governments have used social distancing to stem the spread of COVID-19, but lack evidence on the most effective policy to ensure compliance. We examine the effectiveness of fines and informational messages (nudges) in pr…
Vaccination nudges: A study of pre-booked COVID-19 vaccinations in Sweden
A nudge changes people's actions without removing their options or altering their incentives. During the COVID-19 vaccine rollout, the Swedish Region of Uppsala sent letters with pre-booked appointments to inhabitants ag…
Potential of large language model-powered nudges for promoting daily water and energy conservation
The increasing amount of pressure related to water and energy shortages has increased the urgency of cultivating individual conservation behaviors. While the concept of nudging, i.e., providing usage-based feedback, has …
Language ModelingLanguage ModellingLarge Language Model"I followed what felt right, not what I was told": Autonomy, Coaching, and Recognizing Bias Through AI-Mediated Dialogue
Ableist microaggressions remain pervasive in everyday interactions, yet interventions to help people recognize them are limited. We present an experiment testing how AI-mediated dialogue influences recognition of ableism…