Who's responsible? Jointly quantifying the contribution of the learning algorithm and training data
A learning algorithm $A$ trained on a dataset $D$ is revealed to have poor performance on some subpopulation at test time. Where should the responsibility for this lay? It can be argued that the data is responsible, if for example training $A$ on a more representative dataset $D'$ would have improved the performance. But it can similarly be argued that $A$ itself is at fault, if training a different variant $A'$ on the same dataset $D$ would have improved performance. As ML becomes widespread and such failure cases more common, these types of questions are proving to be far from hypothetical. With this motivation in mind, in this work we provide a rigorous formulation of the joint credit assignment problem between a learning algorithm $A$ and a dataset $D$. We propose Extended Shapley as a principled framework for this problem, and experiment empirically with how it can be used to address questions of ML accountability.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Methods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Quantifying Modality Contributions via Disentangling Multimodal Representations
Quantifying modality contributions in multimodal models remains a challenge, as existing approaches conflate the notion of contribution itself. Prior work relies on accuracy-based approaches, interpreting performance dro…
Joint Covering Congestion Rents in Multi-area Power Systems Considering Loop Flow Effects
We consider the problem of how multiple areas should jointly cover congestion rents of internal and tie-lines in an interconnected power system. A key issue of our concern is the loop flow problem, which represents discr…
SchedulingCopyScope: Model-level Copyright Infringement Quantification in the Diffusion Workflow
Web-based AI image generation has become an innovative art form that can generate novel artworks with the rapid development of the diffusion model. However, this new technique brings potential copyright infringement risk…
Image Generation2D-OOB: Attributing Data Contribution Through Joint Valuation Framework
Data valuation has emerged as a powerful framework for quantifying each datum's contribution to the training of a machine learning model. However, it is crucial to recognize that the quality of cells within a single data…
Data PoisoningData ValuationWho is leading in AI? An analysis of industry AI research
AI research is increasingly industry-driven, making it crucial to understand company contributions to this field. We compare leading AI companies by research publications, citations, size of training runs, and contributi…