A Technical and Normative Investigation of Social Bias Amplification
The conversation around the fairness of machine learning models is growing and evolving. In this work, we focus on one particular component, the issue of bias amplification: the tendency of models trained from data containing social biases to further amplify these biases. By definition, this problem stems from the algorithm, and cannot be attributed to the dataset. We make three contributions regarding its measurement. First, building off of Zhao et al. (2017), we introduce and analyze a new, decoupled metric for measuring bias amplification, $\text{BiasAmp}_{\rightarrow}$, which possesses a number of attractive properties, including the ability to pinpoint the cause of bias amplification. Second, we demonstrate the lack of consistency in values reported by fairness metrics across models that are equally accurate, and encourage the use of confidence intervals when reporting such fairness measures. Finally, we consider what bias amplification means in the context of domains where labels either don't exist at test time, or correspond to uncertain future events. We provide a deeply interrogative look at the technical measurement of bias amplification, guided by our normative ideas of what we want it to encompass.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
FairnessSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Directional Bias Amplification
Mitigating bias in machine learning systems requires refining our understanding of bias propagation pathways: from societal structures to large-scale data to trained models to impact on society. In this work, we focus on…
FairnessDecoding the Black Box: Integrating Moral Imagination with Technical AI Governance
This paper examines the intricate interplay among AI safety, security, and governance by integrating technical systems engineering with principles of moral imagination and ethical philosophy. Drawing on foundational insi…
EthicsMathPhilosophyStructuring the Space of Sociotechnical Alignment
Sociotechnical alignment concerns the social desirability of AI behavior and is thus inherently normative, not merely technical. While NLP research increasingly addresses its technical aspects, it often leaves underspeci…
Towards Identifying Social Bias in Dialog Systems: Frame, Datasets, and Benchmarks
The research of open-domain dialog systems has been greatly prospered by neural models trained on large-scale corpora, however, such corpora often introduce various safety problems (e.g., offensive languages, biases, and…
Bias DetectionOpen-Domain DialogBias amplification in experimental social networks is reduced by resampling
Large-scale social networks are thought to contribute to polarization by amplifying people's biases. However, the complexity of these technologies makes it difficult to identify the mechanisms responsible and to evaluate…
Decision Making