Benchmarking and Enhancing Disentanglement in Concept-Residual Models
Concept bottleneck models (CBMs) are interpretable models that first predict a set of semantically meaningful features, i.e., concepts, from observations that are subsequently used to condition a downstream task. However, the model's performance strongly depends on the engineered features and can severely suffer from incomplete sets of concepts. Prior works have proposed a side channel -- a residual -- that allows for unconstrained information flow to the downstream task, thus improving model performance but simultaneously introducing information leakage, which is undesirable for interpretability. This work proposes three novel approaches to mitigate information leakage by disentangling concepts and residuals, investigating the critical balance between model performance and interpretability. Through extensive empirical analysis on the CUB, OAI, and CIFAR 100 datasets, we assess the performance of each disentanglement method and provide insights into when they work best. Further, we show how each method impacts the ability to intervene over the concepts and their subsequent impact on task performance.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
BenchmarkingDisentanglementMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
ConceptPrism: Concept Disentanglement in Personalized Diffusion Models via Residual Token Optimization
Personalized text-to-image (T2I) generation has emerged as a key application for creating user-specific concepts from a few reference images. The core challenge is concept disentanglement: separating the target concept f…
Semantic Residual for Multimodal Unified Discrete Representation
Recent research in the domain of multimodal unified representations predominantly employs codebook as representation forms, utilizing Vector Quantization(VQ) for quantization, yet there has been insufficient exploration …
DisentanglementQuantizationRetrievalGAN-based disentanglement learning for chest X-ray rib suppression
Clinical evidence has shown that rib-suppressed chest X-rays (CXRs) can improve the reliability of pulmonary disease diagnosis. However, previous approaches on generating rib-suppressed CXR face challenges in preserving …
BenchmarkingComputed Tomography (CT)DisentanglementLung Disease ClassificationEnhancing Knowledge Tracing with Concept Map and Response Disentanglement
In the rapidly advancing realm of educational technology, it becomes critical to accurately trace and understand student knowledge states. Conventional Knowledge Tracing (KT) models have mainly focused on binary response…
DisentanglementKnowledge TracingMisconceptionsMultiple-choiceLearning Disentangled Audio Representations through Controlled Synthesis
This paper tackles the scarcity of benchmarking data in disentangled auditory representation learning. We introduce SynTone, a synthetic dataset with explicit ground truth explanatory factors for evaluating disentangleme…
BenchmarkingDisentanglementRepresentation Learning