Can You Trust Your Copilot? A Privacy Scorecard for AI Coding Assistants
The rapid integration of AI-powered coding assistants into developer workflows has raised significant privacy and trust concerns. As developers entrust proprietary code to services like OpenAI's GPT, Google's Gemini, and GitHub Copilot, the unclear data handling practices of these tools create security and compliance risks. This paper addresses this challenge by introducing and applying a novel, expert-validated privacy scorecard. The methodology involves a detailed analysis of four document types; from legal policies to external audits; to score five leading assistants against 14 weighted criteria. A legal expert and a data protection officer refined these criteria and their weighting. The results reveal a distinct hierarchy of privacy protections, with a 20-point gap between the highest- and lowest-ranked tools. The analysis uncovers common industry weaknesses, including the pervasive use of opt-out consent for model training and a near-universal failure to filter secrets from user prompts proactively. The resulting scorecard provides actionable guidance for developers and organizations, enabling evidence-based tool selection. This work establishes a new benchmark for transparency and advocates for a shift towards more user-centric privacy standards in the AI industry.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Clawed and Dangerous: Can We Trust Open Agentic Systems?
Open agentic systems combine LLM-based planning with external capabilities, persistent memory, and privileged execution. They are used in coding assistants, browser copilots, and enterprise automation. OpenClaw is a visi…
Keras GPT Copilot: Integrating the Power of Large Language Models in Deep Learning Model Development
Keras GPT Copilot is the first Python package designed to integrate an LLM copilot within the model development workflow, offering iterative feedback options for enhancing the performance of your Keras deep learning mode…
Data-to-Text GenerationText GenerationZero-shot Text RetrievalA Vertical Federated Learning Method for Interpretable Scorecard and Its Application in Credit Scoring
With the success of big data and artificial intelligence in many fields, the applications of big data driven models are expected in financial risk management especially credit scoring and rating. Under the premise of dat…
Federated LearningManagementVertical Federated LearningBeyond Autocomplete: Designing CopilotLens Towards Transparent and Explainable AI Coding Agents
AI-powered code assistants are widely used to generate code completions, significantly boosting developer productivity. However, these tools typically present suggestions without explaining their rationale, leaving their…
Code CompletionDecision MakingMultisource AI Scorecard Table for System Evaluation
The paper describes a Multisource AI Scorecard Table (MAST) that provides the developer and user of an artificial intelligence (AI)/machine learning (ML) system with a standard checklist focused on the principles of good…