Closing the Feedback Loop: From Experience Extraction to Insight Governance in Verbal Reinforcement Learning
Training-free verbal reinforcement learning enables LLM agents to learn from world feedback -- objective signals such as dynamic task outcomes, market returns, or demand forecasts -- by extracting verbal rules from experience and injecting them as context, updating the agent's behavior without parameter changes. However, in non-stationary environments these agents face a retention-forgetting dilemma: retaining stale insights causes negative transfer, while discarding them causes catastrophic forgetting when conditions recur. We identify four requirements for navigating this dilemma -- outcome-driven evaluation, persistent structured evidence, non-monotonic knowledge lifecycle, and compositional governance -- and show that existing methods invest heavily in experience extraction while underinvesting in insight governance. We propose a three-layer architecture -- rules, evidence, and skills -- connected by a feedback-driven curation loop that closes the governance gap. Rules capture distilled experience from world outcomes; evidence logs track each rule's reliability across episodes; skills govern which rules to apply, how to resolve conflicts, and when to abstain. On financial forecasting as a case study, where world feedback is naturally abundant, noisy, and non-stationary, we show that the same accumulated experience either degrades performance below the zero-shot baseline or dramatically improves accuracy and risk-adjusted returns, depending on whether the curation loop is present.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Reinforcement LearningSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Fast and Accurate Deep Loop Closing and Relocalization for Reliable LiDAR SLAM
Loop closing and relocalization are crucial techniques to establish reliable and robust long-term SLAM by addressing pose estimation drift and degeneration. This article begins by formulating loop closing and relocalizat…
Point Cloud RegistrationPose EstimationRetrievalUser eXperience Perception Insights Dataset (UXPID): Synthetic User Feedback from Public Industrial Forums
Customer feedback in industrial forums offers rich but underexplored insights into real-world product experience. Yet systematic analysis remains challenging due to unstructured, domain-specific content and the scarcity …
Sentiment AnalysisSWE-Review: Closing the Loop on Issue Resolution with Agentic Code Review
Coding agents increasingly generate pull requests (PRs) for real-world software issues, yet one-shot PR generation remains open-loop: the PR is proposed without systematic review, diagnosis, or revision. We introduce SWE…
Closing the Loop: Unified 3D Scene Generation and Immersive Interaction via LLM-RL Coupling
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have significantly improved language-driven 3D content generation, but most existing approaches still treat scene generation and user interaction as separate processes, lim…
Reinforcement LearningScene GenerationSystem-Level Natural Language Feedback
Natural language (NL) feedback offers rich insights into user experience. While existing studies focus on an instance-level approach, where feedback is used to refine specific examples, we introduce a framework for syste…
Language ModelingLanguage ModellingResponse Generation